Best Kids Clothes Store
| JC PENNEY | KMART | KOHL'S | OLD NAVY | SEARS | TARGET | WALMART | WINNER |
WHY | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price | $597.68 |
$295.47 |
$705.13 |
$386.81 |
$546.40 |
$293.88 |
$218.36 |
Walmart |
Walmart came out far cheaper than any other store we compared. |
| In-Store Availability | 4 items not in store or online |
7 items not in store; all of those items available online |
4 items not in store; 2 of those items available online |
8 items not in store; 3 of those items available online |
All items in store |
6 items not in store; all of those items available online |
9 items not in store; 6 of those items available online |
Sears |
Sears was the only one-stop shop for back-to-school clothes and accessories. |
| Store Brand Quality | Quality tops, average jeans |
Good quality jeans, but tops seemed cheaply made |
Good quality across the board |
High-quality polo shirts and jeans |
Reinforced stitching makes tops high-quality, but jeans are just average |
Decent quality shirts, average quality jeans |
Good quality jeans, but tops tend to shrink |
Kohl's and Old Navy |
Shoppers recommend Kohl's for quality. Old Navy shirts and jeans also proved durable in a test. |
| Coupons | Weekly ad with deals |
Some online coupons |
Card members always get mailed 10, 20, 30 percent-off coupons |
Sends card members coupons |
Weekly ad and deal of the day |
Mails coupons about once a month and has e-coupons (although not always on clothes) |
Some online coupons |
Kohl's |
Frequent storewide sales and coupons for card holders |
| Tops | Very high quality but on the pricey side |
Low prices but not the best quality |
Higher prices but good selection |
Very high quality and decent prices |
Higher prices and somewhat limited boys selection |
Good prices and quality but not a huge selection |
Lowest prices, but quality is just so-so |
Old Navy |
High quality and wide selection for middle-of-the-pack prices |
| Pants and dresses | Wide selection of jeans and dress clothes but a bit pricey |
Limited dress clothes |
Large selection of durable dress pants and dresses |
Limited dress clothes |
Higher prices but broad selection |
Jeans fray easily; no dress clothes selection for girls |
High-quality jeans at the cheapest prices |
Walmart and Kohl's |
Walmart jeans have the lowest prices and also rate high in quality. Kohl's has the broadest selection of dress pants for boys and dresses for girls. |
| Uniforms | Huge selection, decent prices |
Online only but very cheap |
Small selection, middle-of-the-pack prices |
Moderate selection, decent prices |
Moderate selection, decent prices |
Low prices but limited in-store selection |
Low prices but limited selection |
JCPenney |
The biggest selection for relatively cheap prices |
| Pajamas | Runner-up -- moderate prices, good selection |
Very limited selection |
Great selection but a bit pricey |
Online only |
Moderate selection, a little pricey |
Lowest prices but limited selection |
Low prices, many options |
Walmart |
Cheapest prices and decent selection |
| Underwear | Higher prices |
Moderate prices, limited selection |
Higher prices but durable; wide selection of training bras |
Higher prices, limited selection |
Low prices for girls, higher prices for boys |
Moderate prices |
Cheapest prices |
Walmart |
In a category where most stores carry the same brand, Walmart is the cheapest. |
| Shoes | Higher prices and limited selection but good quality |
Low prices, limited selection, and questionable quality |
A bit on the pricey side, but good selection |
Very limited selection |
Higher prices, good quality, many brands to choose from |
Huge selection, low prices |
Lowest prices, decent selection |
Target |
A large selection for all occasions at low prices |
| Outerwear | None |
None |
None |
A few options at the cheapest prices |
Only option is a bit pricey |
Small selection but bigger than most; cheapest prices |
None |
Old Navy |
Stylish options -- a jean jacket for girls and a windbreaker for boys -- at cheap prices |
| Return Policy | Full refund with receipt within 90 days. Can also look up recent credit card transaction if card is present. Store credit for lowest retail price after 90 days or without receipt. |
Full refund or even exchange with receipt and tags within 90 days. Can also look up credit/debit card transaction. No refund without receipt if transaction can't be found. No returns after 90 days. |
Hassle-free returns anytime. Can look up credit/debit card transaction for full refund or even exchange without receipt. If transaction can't be found, store credit is issued for current in-store price. |
Full refund or even exchange with receipt within 90 days. Can also look up credit/debit card transaction. Store credit for current price by mail with no receipt or after 90 days with receipt. |
Full refund or even exchange with receipt within 90 days. Can also try to look up credit/debit card transaction. Store credit for lowest retail price after 90 days or without receipt. |
Full refund or even exchange for unworn items with receipt within 90 days. Can also look up credit/debit card transaction. Store credit for current in-store price without receipt or credit/debit purchase. |
Full refund or exchange with receipt within 90 days. Can also look up credit/debit card transaction if exact date of purchase is given. Store credit for current price without receipt. No returns after 90 days. |
Kohl's |
No 90-day limit on returns and no receipt required. |


