11 Store-Bought Snacks Made Better at Home


Support Cheapism: Do your shopping with our retail partners.

View as:

Photo credit: Marcos Mesa Sam Wordley/shutterstock


In a pinch, store-bought snack foods offer convenience that can be a real timesaver. Over time, however, relying on these familiar ready-made treats can take a toll on the wallet and waistline. Thankfully, there are many ways to enjoy the most beloved of brand-name snacks without spending a lot or consuming unhealthy artificial ingredients. These recipes make it easy to create your own versions of popular snacks at home that are cheaper and often tastier, even if they do take a little more time and effort than simply throwing a cardboard box in a shopping cart.
Photo credit: Tiger Images/shutterstock


All it takes to create goldfish crackers at home is 8 ounces of cheddar cheese, 4 tablespoons of butter, a cup of flour, and instructions from the recipe-sharing site Tasty Kitchen. Choose the cheddar based on desired sharpness, and pulse in a food processor with the flour and butter, plus a dash of salt. Chill the resulting dough, roll it out to cut out the familiar fish shapes (or another of your choosing), and bake in a 350-degree oven until crispy, about 15 minutes. The recipe makes about seven dozen crackers for just over $3, compared with $5 for a similar amount of the Pepperidge Farm version from a discount grocery retailer such as Walmart.
Photo credit: EmiliaUngur/shutterstock


As much a dessert as a breakfast food, Cocoa Puffs is a tasty but sugar-laden cereal that typically costs $3 a box. A homemade version developed by food blogger Laura Fuentes is cheaper and healthier. Substitute some of the flour for a quarter cup of almond meal and use a sweetener such as maple syrup or honey instead of typical table sugar. The resulting cereal is sensitive to some dietary restrictions, but still sweet and tasty enough to please kids.
Photo credit: Constantine Pankin/shutterstock


Cereal bars like Kellogg's Nutri-Grain bars advertise that they include real fruit, though there's often more sugar and corn syrup than actual fruit in the food-dyed fillings. It's easy to beat the $4 price tag for an eight-pack of Nutri-Grain bars simply by using the cheapest seasonal fruit as the sole ingredient for the filling. A granola crust recipe from Super Healthy Kids uses flavorful coconut oil in place of shortening and agave nectar in place of sugar -- although it may be more cost effective to use honey or stevia extract in place of more expensive agave.
Photo credit: Abramova Elena/shutterstock


Like most other candy bars, Snickers are typically sold in individual packs for $1, even though it's quite easy to make a slab of 30-plus similar candy bars at home for far less per bar. Cut the costs while keeping the chocolaty decadence using a homemade Snickers bar recipe from How Sweet It Is. Layer milk chocolate, homemade nougat, caramel, and milk chocolate again to create a batch of treats that are cheaper per bar than even buying in bulk.
Photo credit: BW Folsom/shutterstock


Why spend $4 on a 12-pack of frozen Toaster Strudel pastries when you can make the same amount fresh at home for less, using ingredients you probably already have on hand? The baked pies come out twice as large as the Pillsbury versions and have only 380 calories per oversize pastry, when low-fat cream cheese (sometimes called Neufchatel) is used for the frosting rather than regular cream cheese. Compare that to 400 calories for the same weight of the store-bought brand. Pick your favorite fruit jam to get creative with the filling.
Photo credit: RONORMANJR/shutterstock


Everyone has his or her favorite and least favorite components of Chex Mix, and this recipe from Half-Baked Harvest makes it easy to create a perfect version you can't find in store. Since the recipe contains so many parts, it demands to be made in bulk, but it's delicious and cheap enough to justify large servings. Roast a blend of mixed nuts, bagel chips, pretzels, Chex, and any other bite-size, savory treats along with a generous portion of melted butter and spices -- yet another opportunity to tailor the mix to your liking.
Photo credit: AS Food studio/shutterstock


A single 2-ounce MoonPie contains 220 calories, compared with just 190 per pie in a recipe from Food52, provided you omit the excessive outer layer of semi-sweet chocolate. Better still, it foregoes the food dye, artificial flavorings, and high fructose corn syrup in the store-bought variety, instead favoring natural ingredients such as coconut oil, maple syrup, and oat flour for a treat higher in fiber.
Photo credit: Maslova Valentina/shutterstock


Oreos are among the most beloved of store-bought snacks, even though they contain little more than unhealthier versions of basic ingredients found on the baking shelves of most pantries. Egg, cocoa powder, baking soda, butter, sugar, and a few more kitchen staples go into a homemade version from the recipe site Weelicious. The cookies come out larger, about three times the size of a normal Oreo, and contain about 60 fewer calories than a serving of original Oreos (three cookies).
Photo credit: Hong Vo/shutterstock


Nacho cheese Doritos are delicious and addictive, but there's another way to enjoy the same great flavor without so much artificial cheese dust, courtesy of the recipe and weight-loss site Snack Girl. The only major ingredients are six medium corn tortillas (50 cents) and 3 tablespoons of Parmesan (50 cents or less). Roasted together with vegetable oil, paprika, and chili powder, they make for an equally addictive chip as cheap as it is tasty.
Photo credit: Ramon Antinolo/shutterstock


It's hard to make something like Twinkies nutritious, but a recipe from Bakepedia is about as close as you can get, omitting some of the stranger ingredients found in the popular Hostess snack cakes, including modified corn starch, partially hydrogenated oil, and even beef fat. Instead, use eggs, corn syrup, flour, and a few other basic ingredients to whip up homemade snack cakes with more taste and fewer calories -- 100 fewer, to be exact, than two store-bought Twinkies.
Photo credit: thefoodphotographer/shutterstock


Summer means a surplus of fresh fruit for less at grocery stores, which makes it the perfect time to try making fruit roll-ups with a recipe from the blog Our Best Bites. Any variety of fresh fruit will do, although some may need some added sweetener before baking. Purée the washed (and, if necessary, pitted) fruits in a food processor, spread the mixture in a paper-thin layer on a lined baking sheet, and bake on low (170 degrees, or use a food dehydrator) for six to eight hours. Calories vary depending on the fruit, but homemade fruit roll-ups contain far fewer ingredients than the Betty Crocker version, which uses artificial coloring.