“a helpful & lucid review site for all things budget” — the new yorker

Cheap Coffee Buying Guide

We made our picks based on our usual analysis of features and online reviews but also a blind taste test. A top choice among canned, medium roast coffees is Melitta 100% Colombian (starting at $5.99 for an 11-ounce can), which coffee drinkers praise in online reviews for its rich, mellow flavor and lack of acidity.

Our other pick for best cheap coffee is Folgers' Black Silk (starting at $7.64 for a 27.8-ounce canister), which delivers depth and boldness without the burnt taste of other dark coffees, according to reviewers and our tasters, although they detected a bitter aftertaste. Cafe Bustelo (starting at $3.79 for a 10-ounce can) also wins over dark roast drinkers posting online, although it was too much for our tasters, who declared it acrid. This coffee is strong and thick, designed for cafe con leche and other variations on Cuban-style espresso. Another tried-and-true inexpensive coffee is Eight O'Clock Original (starting at $4.98 for 12 ounces of whole beans), which began as an A&P store brand more than 150 years ago. Experts say it has stood the test of time, awarding it high ratings for its pleasing aroma and smooth, mellow flavor. Dunkin' Donuts Original Blend (starting at $8.99 for 16 ounces) has many detractors but also many admirers, and took the top spot in our taste test in a unanimous verdict.

We used newly opened containers of fresh coffee to conduct our blind test. The panelists were all premium coffee drinkers unfamiliar with these top-rated brands. Each brew was prepared in an automatic Mr. Coffee machine, using 2 tablespoons of ground coffee per 8 ounces of water, and immediately transferred to a thermal container for consistency. The panel tasted the coffees both with and without milk.

How do high-end premium coffees from places like Portland's Stumptown or Brooklyn's Cafe Grumpy command up to $20 a pound, when the coffees in our tasting top out at $8.99? It starts with the sourcing of the beans. Arabica beans tend to produce expensive coffee because they are delicate, grown under shade at higher altitudes, and require more care in cultivation. Robusta beans are cheaper and less flavorful but contain more caffeine. The Dunkin', Melitta, and Eight O'Clock coffees on our list are made from 100% arabica beans, however, so that's far from the whole story.

The beans in premium coffees often come from a single equatorial location or even a particular farm. By contrast, cheap coffees may be a blend of beans from different estates, primarily in Central America, with Colombia predominating. Coffee estates in places such as Ethiopia and Sumatra are unlikely to be represented at the cheap end of the spectrum.Fair Trade and organic designations can also jack up the price. "Fair Trade" means the importer has paid the farmers a fair price, provided credit, and offered technical assistance. Organic farming practices tend to yield less coffee, resulting in higher prices.

The most expensive coffees are extremely fresh, something that's not typically true of cheap coffee. You can expect the grounds at the bottom of a two-pound container to be relatively tasteless. If you're not the type to buy whole beans and grind them yourself, be sure to note the sell-by date on pre-packaged coffee. We talked to a coffee store owner who said there's a noticeable difference in the taste of 30 pounds of vacuum-packed beans from a large roaster vs. beans from a small batch roaster who roasts them to order and delivers them right away. Small batch roasting ensures evenness, with a minimum of unroasted beans in every batch.

Coffee can be roasted anywhere from light to very dark. Darker roasts are usually denser and more intense, although deep roasting can kill off caffeine. Europeans tend to prefer darker brews, while iconic American coffees are generally mild to medium roasts. Still, the coffee revolution that started in Seattle in the 1970s has changed the way many Americans think of coffee. Darker roasts, which used to be hard to come by, are popping up all over the place at affordable prices. Dark roasting is not necessarily a sign of good coffee, however, even in more expensive brands. Certain beans don't lend themselves to deep roasting, and over-roasting makes coffee taste burnt and bitter.

Review continues below

In addition to choosing the best light/medium and dark coffees, we also took a look at cheap flavored and decaffeinated coffees, as well as pods for single-serve coffee makers. Read on to find out which ones promise the most satisfying start to your mornings.

email Sign up for our
Free Newsletter
Cheapism.com on Facebook
Other Reviewed Products
Seattle's Best Coffee Review