“a consumer reports for the cheap” — the new york times

Chocolate Reviews

Chocolate reviews online are sparse, so we supplemented with our own chocolate review. We organized blind tastings that involved two to six panelists and randomly queried about 25 consumers who were shopping for chocolate and collected responses to a question on Facebook that asked friends to name their favorite chocolate bar.

Related Guides:
Champagne, Cheap Red Wine and White Wine
For the hands-on testing we started with a variety of inexpensive chocolate bars that cost less than $4 for 3.5 ounces and included a few that cost a bit more. We also set up blind tastings for boxed chocolate candies (bonbons and truffles), with a price ceiling set at 75 cents for an individual piece. The Facebook effort generated votes for Valrhona, Callebaut, and Green & Black's Organic chocolates, among others, but the favorite was Hershey's Milk Chocolate with Almonds. Although taste is surely subjective, the reviews that we conducted along with the few we found online produced clear winners and losers.

Cheap Variety Chocolates.

Because Hershey's Milk Chocolate with Almonds was frequently named the favorite in our unscientific poll (and before our panel actually tasted any chocolates), we decided to add variety chocolate bars to the chocolate reviews mix. Variety chocolates contain other flavors or add-ins, from almonds or dried fruit to savory delights such as bacon, lavender, or chili. We didn't rank the few we tasted, but solicited opinions and scoped out reviews.

High nostalgia value attaches to Hershey's Milk Chocolate with Almonds (starting at $2.19/4.25 oz.) that fizzled quickly in today's real world. Chocolate reviews posted on Amazon lament that the bar is devoid of whole almonds, and the almond pieces present seem mushy and lack the satisfying crunch and roasted flavor that Hershey's fanciers remember from days gone by. Our panelists were likewise disappointed and declared the milk chocolate to be very sweet and a bit waxy.

Review continues below

Then there's Chocolove's Almonds & Sea Salt in Dark Chocolate (starting at $2.32/3.2 oz.). Consumers who posted chocolate reviews on Amazon and Vitacost consider this bar addictive. Bloggers and our tasters agreed, saying it delivers the sort of deliciousness that makes you swoon: The salt crystals accent the chocolate flavor and the almonds present a full-on almond taste and satisfying crunch.

The Cadbury Fruit & Nut Bar (starting at $2.25/2.4 oz.) is the familiar Cadbury milk chocolate bar with lots of raisin, cashew, and almond pieces. A British favorite that's replicated in the U.S. in slightly altered form, this is a chunky bar with a mellow chocolate flavor and creamy texture. The American version is quite sweet, but as one inexpensive chocolates review on Amazon notes, the combination of textures and tastes delivers a mouthful of joy.

Two other variety chocolate bars bear mention. Green & Black Organic Chocolate is known for its fair trade practices and interesting flavor mix-ins. The Maya Gold (starting at $3.99/3.5 oz.) is an orange-spice flavored treat for serious dark chocolate lovers. The deep chocolate flavor marries well with the orange, and the overall effect is a rich chocolate taste that's just bitter enough. One of our panelists thought the spice should dominate, but a chocolates review on Amazon deemed the spice too heavy-handed. Valrhona Manjari Orange (starting at $5.50/3.5 oz.) is beyond our price range, but reviews indicate it gets the flavor balance just right. With bits of orange peel blended in, the citrus doesn't overwhelm the chocolate, which is slightly bitter. Although one blogger declared the orange chocolate bar falls short of the standard set by the unadulterated Valrhona bar, another blogger found the texture to be smoother and creamier than other bars.

Review continues below

by Elizabeth Sheer (Google+ Profile)

Back to top »

email Sign up for our
Free Newsletter
Cheapism.com on Facebook
From our blog
18 Ways to Cut Your Grocery Bill

From shopping seasonally to buying in bulk, there are plenty of tried-and-true ways to save money on groceries.

A Unique Twist on a Cheap Dinner Party

Love dinner parties but don't like footing the bill? Chaos Cooking provides an innovative way to organize a dinner party on the cheap.

What to Buy (and What Not to Buy) in March

Use this post-holiday, season-transition month to find bargains on frozen and snack foods, fresh produce, and luggage. Don't join the gym just yet or look for a new vacuum cleaner or TV.

All Our Blog Posts