“cheapism helps you find the cheapest "best buys"” — lifehacker
Also see our full Furnace Reviews review:
  1. Furnaces
  2. High-Efficiency Furnace
  3. Gas Furnaces
  4. Furnace Reviews
  5. Discount Furnace Reviews Features Comparison Table
Payne Furnace Review
Payne Furnace 4 Star Rating: Cheapism Good Pick
Summary:
Experts are impressed with the quality and price of Payne furnaces, saying they're reliable, trouble-free, and long-lasting. The brand offers energy-efficient 80% AFUE units with variable-speed blowers. The furnaces are backed by an above-average warranty of 10 years on parts and 20 years on the heat exchanger.

The super-affordable Payne line of gas furnaces -- by far the cheapest on our list -- garners excellent feedback in Payne furnace reviews at WebHVAC and this site. Both sites single out the PG8MEA in their Payne furnace reviews, calling the model reliable, efficient, and cost-effective. Gas Furnace Prices Online notes that an 80% annual fuel utilization efficiency (AFUE) rating makes the PG8MEA a good choice for consumers in mild climates who want to save on equipment costs up front. Many consumers posting Payne furnace reviews on this site say these units run smoothly, last long-term, and present minimal problems, but others complain about having to repeatedly replace the igniter or the control board. A few reviewers note that many manufacturers get parts from the same suppliers, however, and a lot depends on the quality of the installation and service.

Payne furnaces have programmable blowers and a unique four-pass heat exchanger to increase efficiency. The cheapest model has an AFUE rating of 80%, while pricier models are efficient enough to earn an Energy Star label. The units are backed by a competitive warranty: 10 years on parts and 20 years on the heat exchanger.

Payne furnaces are simple and straightforward, with low prices, good warranties, programmable blowers, and Energy Star labels on certain models. Reviewers praise the furnaces' reliability and performance. With proper installation, this brand should be a good bet for frugal homeowners.

By Cheapism editorsOctober 28, 2011
Payne Furnace Deals
Find a Payne Dealer
 

Other Recommended Furnace Reviews

Trane XL80 Furnace
Gold Medal

Trane XL80 Furnace

Professional heating contractors rave about the value of the two-stage furnaces in this series. Having two levels of heat output increases efficiency and reduces wear on the unit. The 80% AFUE rating is adequate for most homes, except those in extremely cold environs. Read more »
Furnace Reviews Deals
Find a Trane Dealer
Carrier Infinity Furnace
Gold Medal

Carrier Infinity Furnace

With a 10-year warranty on parts and 20 years on the heat exchanger, this series of gas furnaces is a safe buy. The Infinity 80 is the cheapest model, offering 80% AFUE, while the Infinity 96 boasts a 96% AFUE. Both have a variable speed blower, which further increases their efficiency. Read more »
Furnace Reviews Deals
Find a Carrier Dealer

Lennox Merit Furnace
Gold Medal

Lennox Merit Furnace

The reliable Lennox Merit Series starts at 80% AFUE and comes with a standard five-year warranty on the covered components and a 20-year warranty on the heat exchanger. Lennox is a brand that receives a lot of hype, but most customers say the attention is deserved because the units are efficient and reliable. Read more »
Furnace Reviews Deals
Find a Lennox Dealer