Best Cheap Paper Shredders
$25 - $75Cheapism
$75 - $300Mid-Range
$300 and upHigh End
- Published on
- ByMaralyn Edid
Identity and other types of data theft -- not to mention all those scary television shows about hoarding -- have made shredding essential for individuals as well as organizations. Unless you want to tear up all your old tax returns by hand, you need a paper shredder. For frugal consumers, that means a cheap paper shredder. Given the array of choices, which one should you choose in the under-$75 set?
AmazonBasics 12-Sheet Cross-Cut Review
This unit does heavy-duty shredding (CDs included) without overheating. It also comes with a safety feature that triggers an automatic shutdown if a foreign object (like tiny fingers) comes into contact with the blade.
Fellowes Powershred W11C Cross-Cut Shredder Review
This durable shredder may be noisy and a bit top-heavy, but it does the job quickly and efficiently. It boasts an 11-sheet capacity and can shred for up to 5 minutes before needing a 20-minute cool down.
Aurora AS420C Desktop-Style Cross-Cut Shredder Review
A small model with a 4.5-inch shredding slot, users nonetheless appreciate its desktop convenience for light use. The Aurora As420C is especially popular with first-time shredder owners who don't want to make a major financial commitment.
Royal CX80 Paper Shredder Review
This fit-anywhere cross-cut shredder features two slots -- one for up to eight sheets of paper and the other for credit cards. A reverse switch comes in handy if you accidentally overfeed the paper slot.
Royal 85MX 10-Sheet Cross Cut Review
Even though this model boasts a 3-gallon basket atop convenient casters, users report inferior performance, with frequent motor stops, jams, and breakdowns.
Cheap Paper Shredders Buying Guide
Some experts say the best time to buy a shredder is in the fall and on through spring tax season. That's when sales are strongest and retailers often put them on special. The most popular brands include Fellowes, Aurora, Royal, and several store brands, such as Staples.
According to our research, the best cheap shredders are the AmazonBasics 12-Sheet Cross-Cut Shredder (starting at $50), which also chews up CDs and credit cards and delivers heavy-duty shredding capacity at an affordable price. The Fellowes Powershred W11C Cross-Cut Shredder (starting at $75), another best pick, provides powerfully reliable performance for personal and home office needs. Our basket of good cheap paper shredders holds the Royal CX80 Paper Shredder (starting at $47), well-liked by buyers for its functionality and easy bin removal. Those who opted for the Aurora AS420C Desktop-Style Cross-Cut Shredder (starting at $29) laud its compact size and portability. One model that doesn't make the grade is the Royal 85MX 10-Sheet Cross Cut (starting at $70) due to reports of performance shortfalls.
Aside from chopping up sheets of paper, many shredders also can do a number on entire envelopes of junk mail, staples and paper clips, credit cards, CDs and DVDs (some of which may contain financial or other personal data). If you expect to need all those capabilities, make sure to choose a cheap paper shredder that can meet them, such as the AmazonBasics 12-Sheet, which boasts a dedicated slot for digital media, or the mid-tier Staples 30-Sheet Strip-Cut Shredder, whose starting price of $120 makes it too rich for our list.
If you have a major project, such as shredding 10 years' worth of medical records or your collection of college journals, think about using a one-time bulk shredding service, such as Shred Nations or Shred-it, which come to your home or office for onsite shredding. Tech Media Network says 30 pounds of paper can be dispensed with for $35 to $40. Shredding at Office Depot costs 99 cents a pound and FedEx charges 79 cents a pound.
What We Looked for in the Specs
Cross-Cut Shredder.There are essentially two kinds of shredders in the budget range: strip cut and cross cut. The former shreds into narrow strips lengthwise or widthwise, depending how you load the paper. The Aurora AS810SD (starting at $30) is an example of a strip-cut shredder. Although they accommodate more paper and are useful for demolishing junk mail, strip-cut shredders are not recommended for sensitive material, as a dedicated identity thief can reassemble these crude cuts fairly easily.
Cross-cut shredders slice and dice paper and other media both vertically and horizontally, creating a confetti-like shape that assures greater security. All of our cheap paper shredder picks are cross-cutters.
Moving up the security ladder gets to models with a micro, or diamond, cut, which turns documents and such into diamond-shaped bits. Micro cut is reserved for high-end shredders that cost upward of $300, well beyond the Cheapism zone.
High Shredding Capacity.The amount of paper a cheap shredder can handle at one time, or in one "pass," is a crucial consideration for most buyers and the basis for many ratings. The standard for units designed for home or small office use ranges from five sheets to 15. Specifications for all the models we researched satisfy this requirement but for the Aurora AS420C, which can take a maximum feed of two sheets of paper folded in half, for a four-sheet thickness (it also can take one credit card). Reviews indicate that not all shredders live up to their advertised capacity (see next page).But don't think just in terms of single sheets. Consider a three-page junk mail letter folded into thirds and inside an envelope. Three pages folded triple is equivalent to a thickness of nine sheets. The two sides of the envelope add two more sheets, for a total of 11. In other words, if you'll be shredding a lot of junk mail, or mailings with multiple sheets, be sure to choose a paper shredder with more stated capacity rather than less. Note, however, that many cheap shredders, like the AmazonBasics 12-Sheet model and the Walmart 6-Sheet Crosscut Shredder (starting at $23), balk at accepting windowed envelopes.
Minimum 8.5-inch Shredding Slot.Most cheap shredders have a similarly sized "throat" through which you feed the material to be shredded. For letter- and legal-sized documents, a throat narrower than 8.5 inches would be tight and likely an exercise in frustration as you struggle to insert the paper.
The 4.5-inch throat on the Aurora AS420C requires that an 8.5x11-inch sheet be folded at least once, but this model sits in our bucket of good cheap paper shredders anyway because of its extremely low price and desktop or stow-away convenience for light personal use. Still, low-key grumbling about throat width surfaces in online review comments.
Safety Features.The best paper shredders have some kind of safety feature. The AmazonBasics 12-Sheet Cross-Cut shredder boasts ShredSafe technology. Effectively, this means that when a foreign object -- human or otherwise -- gets too close to the shredder throat, the unit automatically shuts off. Other brands have their own safety mechanisms. Staples shredders, for example, feature Blade Guard, a mechanical feature that covers the shredder's sharp teeth, and the Fellowes Powershred W11C has a patented safety interlock for shutting down the shredder when the head is taken off the basket.
What We Ignored in the Specs
Bin Style and Capacity.Shredders come in two basic bin styles: pull-out console and wastepaper basket. With the former (found on the Royal CX80), you empty the device by pulling out a basket-size drawer that collects the shreds. With the latter, you lift the shredder mechanism off the basket holding the shreds. The choice is a matter of personal preference, and users note that both can make a mess when dumping into a larger container. (Tip: Line the basket with a bag from the grocery store.)
As with any waste receptacle, the larger it is, the less frequently it must be emptied. Bin sizes for cheap paper shredders generally range from very small, about 1.5 gallons to 8 gallons. Among the models we researched, the Aurora AS420C features the smallest bin (1.3 gallons) and the AmazonBasics 12-Sheet and Fellowes Powershred W11C feature the largest (4.8 and 4.75 gallons, respectively). Several users say the 2.75-gallon bin on the Royal CX80 seems a bit small, but optimal bin capacity really depends on how much shredding you plan to do and how often you want to empty it.
And remember, shredded paper has excellent recycling potential as everything from garden mulch to packing filler.
Paper Shredder Reviews
Shredding capacity -- the ability to get a job done efficiently and without jamming or overheating -- is users' primary interest, according to paper shredder reviews. But a few other features occasionally come under scrutiny, such as run time and durability. We didn't pay attention to comments about noise because shredders invariably are deemed very noisy or just plain noisy.
Shredding Capacity.Paper shredder reviews reveal that many users of the better budget models are satisfied with their ability to chew up paper, and, where relevant, credit cards and other media. But online comments also reveal that some users find that the models we researched don't live up to manufacturers' stated claims about shredding capacity with each pass. (Tip: Make a habit of inserting fewer than the maximum number of sheets; users say doing so puts less stress on the machine and promotes longevity. Also, oiling the shredding mechanism regularly keeps things running smoothly; check manufacturer's instructions.)
The AmazonBasics 12-Sheet Cross-Cut (starting at $50) gets credit in an expert review at Bestcovery for handling the full allotment without jamming or overheating -- CDs and DVDs, as well, according to users' paper shredder reviews, even though a few claim that the machine's comfort level is less than 12 sheets. The Fellowes Powershred W11C (starting at $75) seems to manage its stated 11-sheet capacity without breaking a sweat, assert a majority of paper shredder reviews. Several note that it plows through six to eight sheets but slows down when faced with 11.
The two-slot Royal CX80 (starting at $47) gets an overall "B" from Good Housekeeping, whose experts found that it handles 12 sheets at a time without freezing up even though it's rated for eight. User reviews, however, report that it slows down when confronted with eight sheets but shreds them just fine. Reviews also note that the dedicated credit card slot makes mincemeat of the little plastic rectangles. Paper shredder reviews at Target say the desk-top Aurora AS420C (starting at $29) does its job perfectly well, but strains somewhat with more than one folded sheet.
The Royal 85MX (starting at $70), on the other hand, takes heat from users for jams with just two sheets of paper, never mind the 10 it's supposed to handle. Posts also complain about the difficulty of cleaning out paper that clogs the cutters.