Pharmacy Price Comparison Chart

At each chain in our drugstore comparison, we recorded non-sale prices and calculated the total outlay for eight name-brand products. We then sought out cheaper store-brand versions of the same products, substituting those where available, and recalculated the totals. In cases where the quantity differed, we calculated the cost of the most commonly available quantity based on unit price.


(To our mobile visitors: This chart is too big to display properly on a small screen, so please visit Cheapism.com on your computer.)

ITEM

CVS

RITE AID

WALGREENS

KROGER

TARGET

WALMART

Antacid (750 mg, 96 ct.)

Tums

$5.79

$5.79

$5.99

$4.19

$3.84

$3.84

Store Brand

$4.49

$4.29

$4.79

$3.79

$2.54

$2.00

Clinical-Strength Deodorant (1.6 oz.)

Secret

$8.99

$9.99

$9.49

$8.59

$7.99

$7.92

Store Brand

$5.99
(based on $3.75/oz. for 2 oz. container)

N/A

$7.49

N/A

N/A

N/A

Cold/Flu Remedy (12 fl. oz.)

Vicks NyQuil

$9.99

$17.69
(based on $1.47/oz. for 8 fl. oz. bottle)

$14.24
(based on $1.19/oz. for 8 fl. oz. bottle)

$11.49

$7.99

$7.97

Store Brand

$7.99

$8.49

$8.99
(based on $0.75/oz. for 8 fl. oz. bottle)

N/A

$6.79

$5.97

Dandruff Shampoo (14.2 oz.)

Head & Shoulders

$5.99

$6.29

$5.99

$4.99

$4.99

$4.97

Store Brand

$4.29

$4.49

$4.19
(based on $0.29/oz. for 23.7 oz. bottle)

$2.49

$2.75
(based on $0.19/oz. for 23.7 oz. bottle)

$2.37

Hair Color

Clairol Nice n' Easy

$7.49

$7.99

$7.79

$6.99

$6.99

$6.92

Mascara

Maybelline Volum' Express The Falsies

$7.49

$7.49

$7.99

$6.39

$5.99

$5.94

Liquid Nutritional Supplement (8 oz., 6 ct.)

Ensure

$8.99

$9.49

$8.99

$7.99

$7.99

$7.97

Store Brand

$6.79

$6.79

$7.99

$7.99

$5.99

$5.97

Toothpaste (4 oz.)

Sensodyne Pronamel

$5.99

$6.29

$6.29

$4.99

$4.99

$4.92

Store Brand

$4.79

$4.99

$4.29

$3.89

N/A

N/A

TOTAL

Name Brands Only

$60.72

$71.02

$66.77

$55.62

$50.77

$50.45

Including Store Brands
(Where Available)

$49.32

$54.52

$53.51

$51.62

$44.03

$42.01