“a consumer reports for the cheap” — the new york times
In this review:
  1. Costco or Sam's Club
  2. Costco Membership, Sam's Club Membership
  3. Sam's vs. Costco Shopping Cart
  4. Costco Prices vs. Sam's Prices
  5. Costco vs. Sam's Club Credit, Sam's vs. Costco Club Coupons
  1. Costco Tires, Costco Pharmacy vs. Sam's
  2. Costco Photos vs. Sam's Photos
  3. Costco vs. Sam's Comparison Table
  4. Sam's vs. Costco Verdict
  5. Infographic: Sam's Club versus Costco versus BJ's
Sign up for our
Free Newsletter
Related Guides: Amazon or Walmart, Cheap Eyeglasses, Cheap LCD TVs, Cheap Shipping, Kids Clothes, Lowe's or Home Depot, Outlet Shopping vs. Retail, Price-Matching Policies, Store Return Policies and Walmart, Target, Kmart Showdown

Sam's vs. Costco Departments

The array of departments at both stores is very nearly the same, as is the range of inventory.

At Sam's Club, the main departments are grocery, health and beauty, books, electronics and computers, pets, office supplies, clothing, toys and video games, and baby.

Sam's Club departments also include auto and tires, which includes tools, workbench storage options, and GPS systems; furniture for the living room, dining room, bedrooms, and office; home accessories, such as flooring, lighting, tile, and storage options; jewelry, which includes engagement rings and wedding bands; outdoor and seasonal items, such as patio furniture, grills, Christmas lights, and above-ground pools; and flowers -- Sam's can do the flowers for weddings and events and put together gourmet gift baskets.

The departments at Costco are almost identical to those at Sam's Club and feature similar goods. One of the few differences we found is that Costco sells funeral supplies, including caskets, cremation urns, and pet cremation urns; Sam's Club is not in this line of business. Likewise, Costco offers wedding dresses at select locations and Sam's does not. Additionally, Costco seems to have a smaller selection in certain areas. At our Costco, there were five different toasters for sale compared with 18 at our local Sam's and 17 sets of luggage at Costco vs. 34 at Sam's.

Sam's vs. Costco Payment Methods.

Paying for a full shopping cart can be tricky at wholesale clubs. Cash, check, and debit cards are often the only options. Sam's Club, however, stands out because it also accepts MasterCard and Discover credit cards. Costco takes only American Express credit cards. Both issue their own credit cards, which also can be used for payment.

Review continues below

Costco vs. Sam's Club Credit and Financial Services.

The average shopper probably won't join Sam's or Costco to take advantage of the featured financial services, but these benefits are worth checking out. As with most large retailers these days, each superstore offers its own credit card. Additionally, Costco offers check printing; refinancing and online investing for individuals; and 401(k) plans, credit card processing, payroll services, and check printing for businesses. Sam's Club processes credit cards for businesses and arranges check printing and small business loans through partner banks.

Sam's vs. Costco Coupons and Extra Savings.

Frugal shoppers look for any and every way to save a buck, and coupons equal extra savings. The only coupons Sam's Club offers are eValue coupons, which are available only to Advantage Plus and Business Plus members (as described above, they're loaded onto your membership card). Costco is the clear frontrunner here. For starters, we received Costco coupons in the mail enticing us to join the club the day before beginning our research. (Neither Costco nor Sam's Club was apprised of our plans or had any input into this report.) The coupons were mostly for in-store grocery items, but there were tire coupons and online coupons as well. When buying the membership, we asked about the coupons and were told members periodically receive coupons in the mail. And once you register online as a member, Costco sends emails with coupons for online savings.

by Raechel Conover (Google+ Profile)

Back to top »

Filed in:
Cheap Groceries, Costco, Costco vs Sams, Discount Stores, Groceries, Home-Office, Sams, Shopping, Wholesale

Best Cheap Wholesale Clubs

 
 
Cheapism.com on Facebook
 
Products Mentioned in This Review
Sam's Club Review
Costco Review
 
Weekly Update: Price-Matching Policies Overview, Cheap Beach Gear and More

Mid-May is the perfect time to hunt for an apartment or a temp job. ...

How a Dent or Scratch Can Get You a Discount on Amazon

For consumers who don't mind a dented package or slight scratch, bargains abound on the Amazon Warehouse Deals site.

Update Your Spring Wardrobe at the Thrift Store

Save money on clothes, household items and more by shopping at thrift stores. Learn techniques to help you scour for bargains.