“a helpful & lucid review site for all things budget” — the new yorker
In this review:
  1. Best Cheap Pepper Mills
  2. Electric Pepper Mills and Crank Pepper Mills Comparison
  3. Ceramic Grinder vs. Stainless Steel Pepper Grinder
  4. Pepper Grinders Reviews
  5. Discount Pepper Mills Features Comparison Table

Cheap Pepper Mills Buying Guide

For anybody who's even a bit serious about cooking, ground pepper that comes in a tin just won't do. What your kitchen calls for instead is a cheap pepper mill, one that grinds pepper the moment before it goes into a soup, onto a roast, or atop a plate of salad or pasta.

For pepper to taste like pepper, a grinder is an essential tool.

Like most spices, pepper contains oils that hold the flavor of the spice, which dissipates when exposed to air. Although some very serious cooks swear by high-end Peugeot pepper mills (those big wooden mills with a "mushroom" on top) that go for nearly $100, you can unlock the flavor just as well with a pepper mill that costs less than a quarter of that price.

The fundamental task of a pepper mill, cheap or otherwise, is to grind pepper and produce even, or consistent, particles. All pepper mills work basically in the same way: Two wheels turn against each other, grinding the pepper seeds in the process. Some pricey units, like the Peugeot, first crush the pepper, then send it down a shaft, and finally grind it. Some cooks claim that the best pepper grinders have ceramic grinding mechanisms, and a few inexpensive pepper mills do, but most of the best pepper grinders feature a steel grinder that's perfectly adequate for the task at hand. The plastic mechanisms found in some low price pepper mills are not worth even the small amount of money you'd spend on them unless you want something that's essentially disposable. An important note: If you're considering grinding salt in a pepper mill, you must choose one with a ceramic grinder. Salt will corrode steel mechanisms and the metal will start to come out along with the salt.

Review continues below

For all their similarities, pepper mills vary in design. With a traditional pepper grinder, you turn the top and the pepper comes out the bottom, where the grinding wheels are located. Nowadays you'll find pepper mills with the reverse design; that is, when the pepper grinder stands at ease on a counter or table, the grinding wheels are on the top and you flip it over to grind and release the pepper. There are also pepper mills that you pump instead of turn, and still others: electric pepper grinders that run on batteries and require little, if any, manual effort. Each design has its partisans, primarily based on perceived ease of use.

When searching for the best pepper grinder, other factors also matter. For example, it's certainly convenient to be able to adjust the texture of the grind, and the reviews that we read indicate consumers welcome the opportunity. But experts at Cooks Illustrated assert that it's more important to have a consistent fine grind than an infinite number of grind options. Then, too, you may prefer a pepper mill that doesn't leave pepper residue all over your counter and/or one that's easy to refill and easy to hold, particularly if your hands are greasy or wet.

The cheap pepper mill market is dominated by OXO, William Bound, Vic Firth, Olde Thompson, and Trudeau. All of these manufacturers offer a selection of different types of pepper mills at a variety of price points.

Review continues below

In the course of our research into the best and good cheap pepper mills, we looked at all types of pepper grinders. The hands-down winner for best budget pepper mill is the OXO Good Grips Pepper Grinder 1140700 (starting at $15), which sports an acrylic body, ceramic grinder, and pour-from-the-top design. We chose two good cheap pepper mills -- the William Bounds Key Mill WB-1 Pepper Mill 901 (starting at $20), for its crush rather than grind mechanism and convenient acrylic body, and the Vic Firth Pump & Grind Stainless Steel Pepper Mill STS06PM01 (starting at $13) for a pump design that lets you grind pepper one-handed with a press of your thumb. Two models that didn't make our list include the Chef'n Pepper Ball (starting at $14), which users say is prone to breaking, and the electric Trudeau Graviti 0716907 (starting at $17), which gets dinged by users for malfunctions and its voracious appetite for batteries.

by Elizabeth Sheer (Google+ Profile)

Back to top »

Best Cheap Pepper Mill

OXO Good Grips Pepper Grinder
Gold Medal

OXO Good Grips Pepper Grinder

The OXO Good Grips Pepper Grinder features a clear body and the recognizable OXO black rubber bottom that's easy to, yes, grip. Users love the ease of loading in the pepper, the easy-to-adjust grind (although some would prefer greater variance between the settings), and the volume of pepper that comes out.

Read Full Review and Compare Prices »

Good Cheap Pepper Mills

William Bounds WB-1 Key Pepper Mill
Gold Medal

William Bounds WB-1 Key Pepper Mill

This maker of high-end pepper mills offers this four-inch-high acrylic pepper mill with many of the same grinding qualities of its pricier brethren. This one is a fairly traditional grinder, except that you turn a handle to crush, rather than grind, the pepper. Users like the minimal effort required but some say filling the reservoir can be tricky.

Read Full Review and Compare Prices »
Vic Firth Stainless Steel Pump & Grind Pepper Mill
Gold Medal

Vic Firth Stainless Steel Pump & Grind Pepper Mill

Vic Firth, a maker of quality drumsticks and mallets, offers a line of gourmet products that includes this slim pump-style pepper mill, which dispenses the ground spice with one-handed action. The grind is not adjustable and users note the mill doesn't hold much pepper.

Read Full Review and Compare Prices »
 

Don't Bother

Chef'n Pepper Ball Pepper Mill

With its rabbit ear pump handles that require one hand to operate and a round acrylic body, the Chef'N Pepper Ball's unique look appeals to consumers. But many gripe about durability and say the grind, while adjustable, is completely uneven. A mini version, sold as a set with a salt grinder, starts at $10.

Read more »

Trudeau Graviti Pepper Mill

The intriguing and user-friendly design might make this cheap pepper mill a compelling buy -- just turn it upside down and gravity activates the battery-powered grinding motor -- but consumers complain that the ceramic grinding mechanism jams and breaks, and the six AAA batteries add continuing cost to the upfront investment.

Read more »

Cheapism.com on Facebook
 
25 Items That Actually Cost Less at Whole Foods

We found 25 items that are actually cheaper at Whole Foods.

Weekly Update: Best Cheap Bluetooth Headsets, Cheapest Place to Buy Groceries, & More

April Fool's Day is just around the corner but don't be duped into spending more than necessary. ...

What to Buy and Not Buy in December

December is an excellent month to take advantage of sales on toys, electronics such as TVs, kitchen cookware and more.