“how to find the best cheap products” — kiplinger

Reviews of Grill Performance

Grill reviews for any given model can be few and hard to find, especially for newer models since so many models are available only from certain vendors. Cooking performance is the most common subject of the barbecue grill reviews we found, while durability is a close second.

Even Heating.

A fundamental "must have" in a top barbecue grill is the ability to cook food evenly.
Related Guides:
Air Conditioners, Binoculars, Dehumidifiers, Fans, Ice Cream, Ice Cream Treats, Lawn Mowers, Leaf Blowers, Mosquito Traps, Pools, Sunglasses, Sunscreen and Tents
Based on comments from consumers and experts, all our picks fare well on this front.

The Char-Griller Grillin' Pro 3001 (starting at $186) earns praise from users posting gas grill reviews at Lowe's for consistent heat across its three burners. In reviews posted on Amazon, consumers say the grill heats up and cooks food quickly. At Home Depot, where the Brinkmann Grill King (starting at $199) is exclusively sold, reviews from numerous users report that the grill heats up fast and cooks very evenly. The Weber One-Touch Gold 22.5 (starting at $149) earns top ratings in charcoal grill reviews at Walmart, where users praise Weber's indirect cooking method, which keeps foods such as chicken and turkey from drying out.

Review continues below

The Char-Broil Two-Burner Gas Grill (starting at $80) doesn't fare so well in a grill review on About.com. The site's resident expert evaluates a version exclusive to Sears and reports that the heat output is decent but not even, and the thin body doesn't hold in heat.


Perhaps surprisingly, many consumers provide positive feedback on the lifespans of the best budget grills. Gas grill reviews on Amazon deem the Char-Griller 3001 durable and seem to consider it an excellent value for the money. Many consumers appreciate the sturdy construction. One used the grill at least once a week for three years before having to spend $5 to replace a worn-out flame deflector. On the other hand, among the nearly 200 mostly positive reviews of the Char-Griller 3001 at Lowe's, we noted a few that complain about rusting, leaking grease and propane, and problems with the ignition.

Review continues below

The Char-Griller Wrangler 2123 (starting at $110) gets a thumbs-up from The Gas Grill Review, which declares the grill more solidly built than its cheap price might suggest. One user vouches for that in a charcoal grill review at Home Depot: Since she bought it for her husband more than five years ago, she says, it's stood outside through snow, rain, and wind and been used three to four times per month, and it's still going strong. The Weber One-Touch Gold likewise wins praise from grillers for its durability. A grill review at Bobby's Best notes that Weber grills come with a 10-year warranty and wagers that this grill will last for 25 years.

In a review of the Brinkmann Grill King 810-2410-SB on Home Depot, one user writes that the grill is still holding up well after six seasons. However, there are some reports of rust developing after a few years and some reviewers suggest the burners and starter are apt to quit working.

The Char-Broil Two-Burner Gas Grill is the subject of an alarming report on Amazon: A repeat buyer who was happy with a previous version for five years says flames flared out the front of this model and melted the knobs. Other consumers echo comments from that reviewer about the flimsy construction of this grill.

by Raechel Conover (Google+ Profile)

Back to top »

Sign up for our
Free Newsletter
Cheapism.com on Facebook
From our blog
How to Make Homemade Pizza for Under $10

Homemade pizza is cheaper than takeout or delivery. Try these recipes, including one for a crust from scratch.

What to Buy in September

This month grab savings on mattresses, cars, appliances, summer gear, school supplies and more.

How to Buy a Futon on a Tight Budget

A futon may be the answer for folks living on a tight budget in a small space. Choose a wood or metal frame and a mattress that provides comfort.

All Our Blog Posts