“a consumer reports for the cheap” — the new york times
In this review:
  1. Cheap Elliptical Trainers
  2. Cheap Elliptical Machines Stride Length, Resistance
  3. Elliptical Reviews
  4. Best Elliptical
  5. Discount Ellipticals Features Comparison Table
Sign up for our
Free Newsletter
Related Guides: Running Shoes and Treadmills

Elliptical Machines Features

Elliptical Machines Stride Length.

Stride length is the most important feature to check when shopping for an elliptical machine.
Your leg movement should feel elliptical (i.e., like a stretched-out oval) and not circular or bouncy, which happens when the stride length is too short. Experts at All Ellipticals recommend that users taller than 5'7" choose a model with a minimum 20-inch stride length, but our research found that this standard would eliminate cheap elliptical machines with shorter strides that are otherwise worthy buys. Longer strides make for more challenging workouts but users with shorter legs or those who may be out of shape or constrained by a physical ailment may prefer a shorter stride. Some pricier elliptical machines accommodate improving fitness levels with a stride length that can be adjusted -- up to 32 inches on the Yowza Captiva (starting at $1,999, Amazon), for example -- but fixed stride length is the norm among cheap elliptical machines.

We found cheap elliptical machines with stride lengths in the 12- to 20-inch range. The Horizon EX69 (starting at $799, Amazon) boasts a 20-inch stride, while the Schwinn 420 (starting at $500, Amazon), ProForm 590E (starting at $582, Amazon), and Nautilus E514 (starting at $537, Amazon) each feature an 18-inch stride. Two cheap elliptical machines with particularly short stride lengths are Gold's Gym StrideTrainer 380 (starting at $277) with a14-inch stride and the Weslo Momentum 630 (starting at $229, Amazon) with a 12-inch stride. Two models that break the cheap mold are the NordicTrack Pathfinder (starting at $700), whose 18-inch stride automatically extends to 20 inches when the adjustable incline is set at the two steepest angles, and the ProForm ZE5 (starting at $599, Amazon), whose stride length can be adjusted to 13, 15, and 18 inches.

Elliptical Machines Resistance.

Resistance -- the tension you feel while pedaling -- is caused by braking on the flywheel. The tighter the brake's grip, the greater the resistance and the tougher the workout. Cheap ellipticals generally come with pre-set resistance levels; the more, the better. The Schwinn 420, Horizon EX69, ProForm 590E, and Nautilus E514 each feature16 resistance levels, and users report that even the lowest level on some of these models is a challenge. By contrast, the Weslo Momentum 630 features 10 resistance levels and Gold's Gym StrideTrainer 380 specs only indicate the resistance can be changed digitally.

Elliptical Machines Workout Programs.

Cheap ellipticals also feature preset workout programs oriented around fitness goals, such as fat burning or cardio; targets, such as distance or speed; or performance, such as interval training or hills. The most generous of the elliptical machines on our list is the ProForm 590E with 20 programs and the most limited is the Weslo Momentum 630 with two preset workouts. The Nautilis E514 lets you customize workouts for two users and the Schwinn 420 gives you that option for one user.

Review continues below

Elliptical Trainers Incline.

Ellipticals with an adjustable incline (i.e., ramp) keep your workout varied and challenging. A steeper incline increases the intensity of the workout and isolates different muscle groups (glutes, quads, calves) from those used on flatter angles. One of the premier features of the NordicTrack Pathfinder is its motorized power ramp, which has five incline settings that go from 15 to 35 degrees. Manual adjustments can be made on the Horizon EX69 (five positions) and ProForm 590E (four positions).

Elliptical Trainers Pedals.

The pedals on an elliptical trainer should be larger than your foot so your toes don't jam up against the front. Most pedals on cheap elliptical machines offer some sort of traction so your foot doesn't slide off. Articulating foot pedals, featured on the Schwinn 420, align with the elliptical motion of the machine to keep your foot flat on the pedal throughout the workout. Pedals on a good elliptical trainer should also be close together; if too far apart, the action stresss your back, hips, and knees. The Horizon EX69 is the only model on our list that boasts "zero gap" pedals; that is, there's no space between them so they overlap as they move.

Elliptical Trainers Footprint.

Any good cheap elliptical needs a large enough base for stability but not so large that it consumes half the room it's in. Our top picks measure at least 62 inches long by 22 inches across; the pricey Sole E95 (starting at $1,700, Amazon) is 82" long and 27 inches wide. The Weslo Momentum 630 is diminutive by these standards; its 44"x21" footprint is well suited to small spaces, and one review notes that it easily fits on board a boat, which lets its owners stay in shape while cruising from port to port.

Review continues below

Most cheap elliptical machines have wheels so you can move them around. The base and pedals on the Nautilus E514, NordicTrack Pathfinder, and ProForm ZE5 fold, which preserves valuable floor space when sitting idle.

Elliptical Trainers Extras.

Niceties such as an MP3 port, fan, and water bottle holder aren't necessary but can add fun and comfort to your workout. The Horizon EX69 features an MP3 port and speakers, as does the ProForm 590E; the latter is also compatible with iFit Live technology, which offers access (for a price) to a different set of workouts. A fan is built into both these models, as well as in the Nautilus E514; one 5'3" user of the Horizon EX69 sadly notes the fan blows onto her forehead. Three of our top picks and the Gold's Gym StrideTrainer 380 provide space for a water bottle. The Schwinn 420 comes with the screws to attach a bottle holder but users' reviews express puzzlement about why the holder itself isn't included.

All the low-cost elliptical trainers we researched have sensors in the hand grips that ostensibly measure your heart rate while exercising. The catch is, you must keep your arms steady. Users often question the accuracy of these readings and some say you get a truer read by checking your pulse with fingers and a clock. The Nautilus E514 also comes with a wireless chest strap for heart rate monitoring, a feature more commonly found at the higher end of the market.

Back to top »

Best Cheap Elliptical Trainers

Schwinn 420
Gold Medal

Schwinn 420

Some experts consider the Schwinn 420 one of the best ellipticals for less than $1000. It may lack a few bonus features, but its quiet, smooth, and sturdy performance more than compensate. Read more »
Ellipticals Deals
Horizon EX69
Gold Medal

Horizon EX69

This is the budget buy for consumers who want to replicate at home the elliptical experience enjoyed at a gym. A solid build, 20-inch stride length, and overlapping pedals offer ergonomically-correct and challenging workouts. Read more »
Ellipticals Deals

Good Cheap Elliptical Trainers

Nautilus E514
Gold Medal

Nautilus E514

You won't find fancy features on this model, but it's well built, quiet, and smooth. If you want to be sure your heart rate is in the target zone while exercising, the wireless chest strap ensures accuracy. Read more »
Ellipticals Deals
ProForm 590E
Gold Medal

ProForm 590E

The ProForm 590E is all about the features, but it also offers a decent workout. The manually-operated incline isolates different muscle groups and plenty of preset workout programs provide motivating variety. Read more »
Ellipticals Deals
 
 
Cheapism.com on Facebook
 

Don't Bother Cheap Ellipticals

Weslo Momentum 630

The very short stride length suits users who are very short, very light, or gunning for a low-intensity workout. Many users report it's noisy and wobbly. Read more »

Gold's Gym StrideTrainer 380

This is an entry-level elliptical trainer with a relatively short stride that many users say is good enough but hard to assemble and sometimes a bit shaky. It's the only model we researched that runs on batteries; an AC adapter is available. Read more »

 
Cheap Bachelor Party Ideas

If you're planning multiple bachelor parties this summer, here are several ideas for a cheap bachelor party that will leave you with cherished memories but not a battered budget.

May 3rd Daily Deals - Rowing Machine Deal, Discount HDTV, and more

Today's top deals include a $460 HDTV marked down to $220 and a $250 rowing machine for $99.

April 19th Daily Deals - 2 Cheap Tablets, Discount Treadmill, and more.

Today's deals include two cheap tablets (Acer and Dell), an Asus laptop, a cheap treadmill, and more.