“cheapism helps you find the cheapest "best buys"” — lifehacker
In this review:
  1. Best Cheap Ice Cream Makers
  2. Ice Cream Maker Reviews
  3. Discount Ice Cream Makers Features Comparison Table

Cheap Ice Cream Makers Buying Guide

Ice cream is a simple treat: cream, sugar, and some flavoring. But choosing a cheap ice cream maker can be tough.

Related Guides:
Blenders, Bread Makers, Coffee Grinders, Espresso Machines, Juicers, Microwaves, Mixers, Popcorn Machines, Rice Cookers, Slow Cookers, Toaster Ovens and Toasters
Surprisingly, some of the ice cream makers that require the most work -- that is, hand-churn machines -- happen to cost the most. Other ice cream makers seem cheap enough and easy to use but produce unsatisfying results. We found several inexpensive ice cream makers that cost no more than $45 and can churn out a cold, rich, creamy treat in about 30 minutes.

Ice cream machines range in price from less than $25 to $200 and more. A few just make ice cream, but most models can whip up sorbets, frozen yogurt, and other chilled delights. The ice cream makers on our list stick mostly to the basics, providing no-fuss, no-mess ways to produce homemade ice cream. The major players in the inexpensive ice cream makers market include Cuisinart, Deni, and Hamilton Beach. Cuisinart leads the pack with a range of models, beginning with its Cuisinart ICE-20 1.5 Quart Ice Cream Maker (starting at $42) and topping out with the Cuisinart ICE-50BC Supreme Ice Cream Maker. Deni sells a variety of related products, including a $30 yogurt maker and a $70 soft-serve maker. Hamilton Beach models typically hover around the $25-$30 price point and include half-pint, 1.5-quart, and 4-quart ice cream makers.

Most cheap ice cream makers require advance planning. That is, you have to freeze the canister in which the ice cream is made for at least eight hours -- the Rival GC9155 (starting at $40) canister requires at least 24 hours of freeze time -- and make sure the ingredients are well chilled; many consumers fast forward the process by storing the canister in the freezer when not in use. Also note that the finished product is more like a firm soft-serve ice cream than the hard store-bought variety. Many ice cream lovers say the homemade version is best enjoyed immediately. But if you prefer a firmer consistency, just freeze the product for several hours before eating -- and remember to transfer it from the canister (preferably with a plastic utensil) to another container before placing in the freezer.

Review continues below

Committed ice cream eaters will find that investing in a cheap ice cream maker can save a ton of money over the long run. According to SoundMoneyMatters.com, if you exclude the price of the actual machine and staples you have on hand (like sugar and vanilla), the total cost of making 1.5 quarts of homemade ice cream is less than $3. This compares to $5 or so for 1.75 quarts of Breyers ice cream and at least $3 for a pint of Ben & Jerry's. So let's start churning.

Freezing Process.

The first decision you'll need to make is which type of cheap ice cream maker to buy: rock salt/ice, freezer bowl, or compressor freezer.

Rock salt/ice machines are powered manually or electrically. The manual variety involves placing the ingredients bowl inside a larger bowl, filling the space between with a mixture of rock salt and ice, and cranking by hand. The electric variety follows the same procedure except that the machine paddles the mixture on its own. One rock salt/ice manual ice cream maker on our list is the electric Hamilton Beach 68330R 4-Qt. Automatic Ice Cream Maker (starting at $30); another is the Industrial Revolution Play & Freeze (starting at $25 for the one-pint size, and $35 for the quart size), but instead of the traditional cranking motion, you (and family and friends) kick or toss the ball-shaped maker to churn up the frozen treat. You can also have it both ways with the six-quart Classic Electric/Crank Ice Cream Maker (starting at $80), which, as its name implies, can be powered by your arm muscles or the nearest electric outlet.

Review continues below

Cheap freezer bowl ice cream makers use a bowl with two walls, in between which is a gel that does the job of ice and salt. After leaving the bowl in the freezer for a minimum of eight hours, just place the bowl on top of the ice cream maker, turn on the motor, and add the ingredients. The Cuisinart ICE-20, Deni 5205 Automatic Ice Cream Maker (starting at $43), and Rival GC9155 are all inexpensive freezer-bowl ice cream makers.

Compressor freezer ice cream makers are no-fuss electric machines. Just add the ingredients right inside the ice cream maker, flip the switch and the paddle gets to work -- no rock salt or ice, no pre-freezing the bowl. Compressor freezer ice cream makers are way beyond the Cheapism range, but in case you're in the mood to splurge, you might investigate the Cuisinart ICE-50BC Supreme Ice Cream Maker or Lello 4070 Gelato Junior (starting at $173).

Quantity.

Many cheap ice cream makers produce 1.5 quarts of ice cream. The exceptions on our list include the Cuisinart ICE-20, which makes two quarts and the Hamilton Beach 68330R, which makes four quarts; the Play & Freeze gives you one pint of ice cream but as noted above, there's also a one-quart version. Keep in mind that 1/2 cup of ice cream is considered one serving, so figure on eight servings in a quart.

Size and Weight.

Although cheap ice cream makers produce about the same amount of ice cream, they vary in size and weight. The Play & Freeze is the lightest and smallest ice cream maker on our list; available in two sizes (eight- or nine-inch diameter, weighing 26 ounces and 40 ounces respectively), it is designed for child's play. The Rival GC9155 Gel Canisteris a hefty 10.8 pounds, but measures 8x8x11 compared to the Cuisinart ICE-20, which weighs nine pounds and measures 10x10x15 inches. The Deni 5205 Automatic Ice Cream Maker weighs a bit less (7.2 pounds) but takes up about as much space (10x9x14 inches) as the Cuisinart ice cream machine. The Hamilton Beach 68330R is a bit larger (12x12x13.5 inches) but weighs just six-and-a-half pounds.

Extra Features.

On the off chance that one night you'll crave some kind of frozen treat other than a sundae, you're in luck with any one of several cheap ice cream makers. Most budget models also churn out one or more cold delights, such as frozen yogurt, sorbet, gelato, slushies, and grown-up drinks. But if you're seeking a few frills in the budget ice cream maker range, about the only "extra" you'll find is the candy crusher atop the Deni 5205. The Hamilton Beach 68220 1.5-Quart Ice Cream Maker (starting at $25), features an extra-large opening that makes it easy to add bits and chunks of candy, fruit, or cookies near the end of the mixing process; this model also has a carrying handle.

by Maralyn Edid (Google+ Profile)

Back to top »

Best Cheap Ice Cream Makers

Cuisinart ICE-20 1.5 Quart Ice Cream Maker
Gold Medal

Cuisinart ICE-20 1.5 Quart Ice Cream Maker

The Cuisinart ICE-20 features a transparent top, removable mixing arm, and a non-stick chamber. Most users love its ease of use (no salt or ice required), consistently creamy ice cream in 20 minutes, and sturdy build. In the unlikely event this machine breaks, it's backed by a three-year warranty, the longest of any we researched. You can save a few dollars by buying a refurbished unit.

Read Full Review and Compare Prices »
Industrial Revolution's Play & Freeze Ice Cream Maker
Gold Medal

Industrial Revolution's Play & Freeze Ice Cream Maker

This innovative approach to ice cream making is roundly lauded by adults and kids. The Play & Freeze is a lightweight polycarbonate "ball" that makes good ice cream in less than 30 minutes by being kicked or thrown around; it needs no electricity so you can take it anywhere. This one-pint model comes in a variety of colors; the quart version costs about $10 more.

Read Full Review and Compare Prices »

Good Cheap Ice Cream Makers

Hamilton Beach 68330R 4-Quart Automatic Ice-Cream Maker
Gold Medal

Hamilton Beach 68330R 4-Quart Automatic Ice-Cream Maker

Favorable reviews for ice cream quality and quantity (four quarts, which is more than any other model on our list) for the Hamilton Beach 68330R, which features an easy-lock lid that lets you watch the process. Some users report it's noisy and some say the motor jams.

Read Full Review and Compare Prices »
Deni 5205 Automatic Ice Cream Maker
Gold Medal

Deni 5205 Automatic Ice Cream Maker

The Deni 5205 is the only cheap ice cream maker on our list with any frills -- in this case, a candy crusher. Consumers like the ice cream but say the candy crusher is relatively useless. The Deni 5205 features a transparent lid, anti-slip rubber feet, and cord storage, and comes in several colors. Two models without the candy crusher, the 5200 (clear) and 5201 (color choices), are a few dollars cheaper.

Read Full Review and Compare Prices »
 

Don't Bother

Rival GC9155 Gel Canister 1-1/2-Quart 2-Piece Electric Ice-Crea

In a variety of ways, the Rival GC9155 underperforms its rivals. Users complain it takes longer than 30 minutes to make ice cream, which often has a slushy, rather than solid, consistency. You have to freeze the bowl for at least an entire day before proceeding, and it weighs a hefty 10.8 pounds; users also gripe about faulty parts.

Read more »

Cheapism.com on Facebook
 
What to Buy and Not Buy in December

December is an excellent month to take advantage of sales on toys, electronics such as TVs, kitchen cookware and more.

4 Unexpected Items Yield Big Savings on Black Friday

We identified several Black Friday deals that may not pass as gifts for others but will make you and your home feel special this year.

What to Buy in September

This month grab savings on mattresses, cars, appliances, summer gear, school supplies and more.