“where cheap is chic” — wisebread
In this review:
  1. Store Return Policies
  2. Store Return Policy Comparison

Guide to Retailers' Return Policies

Let's be honest: Some purchases and some gifts just cry out to be returned. Perhaps you discover a defect in the product or develop a case of buyer's remorse.

Related Guides:
Airline Fees, Amazon or Walmart, Cell Phone Fees, Cheap Eyeglasses, Cheap LCD TVs, Cheap Laptops, Cheap Shipping, Costco or Sam's Club, Grocery Stores, Kids Clothes, Lowe's or Home Depot, Outlet Shopping vs. Retail, Price-Matching Policies, Walmart, Target, Kmart Showdown and Whole Foods on a Budget
Perhaps you receive a gift or give one that aims to please but doesn't. Most retailers maintain return policies to accommodate such situations and some are more understanding during the holiday season, when they institute special store return policies for items purchased in November and December. Every vendor adheres to its own set of rules, which makes the whole return thing quite complicated. Ever the frugal shopper's friend, Cheapism decided to pull together a consumer-friendly guide to the store return policies of 22 of the country's largest retailers.

We compared standard store return policies to those adopted during the holiday season and identified some standouts. Macy's and Kohl's, for example, win our favor for their lenient return rules all year. JC Penney and L.L. Bean likewise earn gold stars for their straightforward and open-ended store return policies regardless of the season. Online retailer Overstock sits at the bottom of the list due to tight restrictions on refunds in general and miserly rules for holiday purchases. This chart summarizes the data we gathered.

We were surprised to find that less than one-third of the retailers we researched offer extra time to return holiday gift purchases. And those that do -- Amazon, Barnes & Noble, Best Buy, Overstock, Sears, Target, and Walmart -- merely extend the regular return period, which often amounts to 30 days but may be as short as 14 days, into January.

Upon closer examination, however, it became clear that most store return policies are already more generous than the temporary holiday return rules instituted by a handful of vendors in our survey. Five stores on our list -- Bath & Body Works, JC Penney, Kohl's, L.L. Bean, and Macy's -- accept returns year-round for an unlimited period. Twelve retailers -- Cabela's, Foot Locker, Gap, Home Depot, Kmart, Lowe's, Sears, Target, Toys R Us, Victoria's Secret, Walmart, and Zappos -- keep the returns window open far longer than 30 days for many, if not all, items. (Some retailers have different store return policies for different merchandise, which is why Sears, Target, and Walmart show up in two of the groupings above.) GameStop maintains a strict and time-limited policy at all times and makes no allowances for holiday purchases.

Many of the store return policies we reviewed use similar language and outline very similar rules. Some common threads among retailers' standard return policies were easy to pick out. For example, for vendors with both an online and offline presence, returning items bought online to a storefront is generally hassle-free. If you send back an item, the retailer may not allow an exchange for a different product and typically will charge shipping costs against the refund unless the product arrives damaged or in error. A few vendors assess a flat return fee and fewer still (e.g., Foot Locker, if the return is made within 30 days, and Gap) cover the cost of return shipping.

We also found that retailers almost always issue refunds in the same form as the initial payment. In other words, if you paid with cash, you'll get cash back; if you paid with a gift card, you'll receive a new gift card; etc.

Store return policies also contain exceptions. Because of the ease with which someone can rip or install software and copy music, movies, and video games, or just use media for a few days (think ebooks), these items rarely can be returned, although defective copies can be exchanged. Similar store return policies typically prevail for collectibles, such as baseball cards and action figures, whose value drops precipitously once the packaging has been opened. Gift cards, personalized items, hazardous materials and firearms, grocery items, health care products, clearance merchandise, and the like almost never are accepted for return.

Review continues below

Note that most store return policies require a receipt or invoice for a refund. L.L. Bean is an exception to the rule, as is Walmart, where customers returning items in-store can get cash back for purchases under $25, no questions asked. Some retailers, including Best Buy, Cabela's, Bath & Body Works, and JC Penney, often ask for a photo ID when customers return items to brick-and-mortar locations so they can keep an eye out for abuses of their policies. Store return policies occasionally are more lenient when it comes to offering an exchange or granting store credit absent proof of purchase. Cabela's, Bath & Body Works, Kohl's, L.L. Bean, and Walmart, for example, allow this practice. With the proliferation of computerized sales systems, however, many retailers, including Home Depot, Kohl's, Lowe's, and Target, can retrieve past transactions within an allotted time frame if you present the credit card used for the original purchase (sometimes a phone number will do).

Gift recipients often must follow a slightly different set of store return policies. Upon request many vendors supply a gift receipt that must be presented when visiting the returns window, and gifts ordered online come with an invoice and/or packing slip. Returned gifts almost always qualify for store credit rather than a refund, and normal return shipping policies apply; Walmart offers pre-paid shipping only for a replacement if something is wrong with an item.

Always hold on to the original packaging (including the shipping box) regardless whether you bought the item or received it as a gift. And think twice before tearing the product packaging apart. Many retailers won't take back certain merchandise that's been opened, particularly media items (e.g., video games and music) and jewelry. Other retailers, such as Overstock, Toys R Us, and GameStop, reduce the refund or allow only an exchange for an identical item when the original packaging has been opened. Always, always read the fine print in any store return policy.

For a different take on holiday store return policies, Consumer World highlights changes from prior years for many major retailers.

by Louis DeNicola (Google+ Profile)

Back to top »

Best Store Return Policy

Zappos Return Policy
Gold Medal

Zappos Return Policy

The Zappos return policy offers a full 365 days from the purchase date to return an item. Return shipping is free -- a rare treat in the retail marketplace.

Read Full Review and Compare Prices »
JC Penney Return Policy
Gold Medal

JC Penney Return Policy

JC Penney's return policy is unbelievably straightforward. There's no deadline for making a return and you can exchange an item without a receipt or return it for a gift card. Although the retailer doesn't condone the practice, even items that have been worn can be returned as long as they appear new. Customers can call a 24/7 support line for help.

Read Full Review and Compare Prices »
Kohl's Return Policy
Gold Medal

Kohl's Return Policy

The Kohl's no-questions-asked return policy sets no time limits but requires proof of purchase and says goods must be in new condition for a full refund. Credit card transactions can be traced back one year for customers lacking a receipt or invoice.

Read Full Review and Compare Prices »
L.L. Bean Return Policy
Gold Medal

L.L. Bean Return Policy

The return policy at L.L. Bean is grounded in the company's 100 percent satisfaction guarantee. The return period is open-ended and no proof of purchase is required for a refund, exchange, or store credit.

Read Full Review and Compare Prices »
Macy's Return Policy
Gold Medal

Macy's Return Policy

Macy's, a retailer with a national and online presence, accepts returns for an unlimited time. Without proof of purchase, however, the company will refund the lowest retail price during the past 180 days.

Read Full Review and Compare Prices »
Walmart Return Policy
Gold Medal

Walmart Return Policy

A 90-day return period holds for most in-store and online purchases. The retailer does not require a receipt for returns made at a store, and if the item cost less than $25, you can turn it in for cash.

Read Full Review and Compare Prices »

Amazon Return Policy
Gold Medal

Amazon Return Policy

The standard Amazon return policy gives customers a 30-day window. In most product categories the customer is responsible for shipping charges, but select merchandise qualifies for free return shipping.

Read Full Review and Compare Prices »
Bath & Body Works Return Policy
Gold Medal

Bath & Body Works Return Policy

Bath & Body Works' return policy is backed by a 100 percent satisfaction guarantee, which means if you're not satisfied with a purchase you can return it to any location or by mail at any time.

Read Full Review and Compare Prices »
Cabela's Return Policy
Gold Medal

Cabela's Return Policy

No matter when you buy something, the Cabela's return policy gives you 90 days to decide if you want to keep the item.

Read Full Review and Compare Prices »
Foot Locker Return Policy
Gold Medal

Foot Locker Return Policy

The Foot Locker return policy is relatively customer-friendly, with a 90-day window for a refund and 365 days for a gift card. Foot Locker also foots the bill for shipping if you exchange an online purchase within 30 days of receiving the order (but not if you return it).

Read Full Review and Compare Prices »
Gap Return Policy
Gold Medal

Gap Return Policy

The Gap return policy gives you 45 days from the date of purchase to decide whether to keep the item or offload it and includes no reprieve for holiday purchases. Gap is one of the few retailers to offer free return shipping for online orders, with a pre-paid UPS label.

Read Full Review and Compare Prices »
Victoria's Secret Return Policy
Gold Medal

Victoria's Secret Return Policy

The Victoria's Secret return policy stands out because, unlike other retailers, it allows customers to return undergarments, the primary type of merchandise the store sells.

Read Full Review and Compare Prices »
 

Don't Bother

Overstock Return Policy

This online vendor issues only partial refunds for all open items, a policy that seems punitive compared with others that typically impose similar restrictions on only a select few product categories. Overstock gives holiday gift buyers and recipients a bit of breathing room by extending its standard 30-day return period into January.

Read more »

Cheapism.com on Facebook
 
Is Raising Chickens Cheaper Than Buying Eggs?

Raising chickens at home comes with upfront costs but eventually helps your food budget.

Weekly Update: Best Cheap Bluetooth Headsets, Cheapest Place to Buy Groceries, & More

April Fool's Day is just around the corner but don't be duped into spending more than necessary. ...

Cheapest Place to Buy Groceries: Walmart, Kroger, or Aldi?

Cheapism.com examines three different models for selling groceries, Kroger, Walmart, and Aldi, in a three-way comparison.