Cheapism is editorially independent. We may earn a commission if you buy through links on our site.

Fried chicken sandwich on toasted bread with lettuce, pickles, and sauce.
ianjmcg – Reddit

When preparing homemade sandwiches, people have an infinite range of possibilities, limited only by the flavors they happen to be craving that day and their own willingness to craft the perfect sandwich. We’re sharing some homemade creations from Reddit users that truly surprised us!

Sandwich & Potato Chips

A club sandwich on multigrain bread served with a pile of potato chips on a plate.
winter_beard – Reddit

Reddit user winter_beard, who lives in St. Louis, revealed that, to create this sandwich, he combined bread, mayonnaise, shredded iceberg lettuce, American cheese, hard salami, smoked turkey, bacon, ham, pickles, salt and pepper, thinly sliced onion, and spicy mustard. User adidashawarma mentioned: “You made me crave a deli sandwich. My ideal sandwich would be if I added tomato and herbed havarti.”

Fresh Lemon Buttercream and Strawberry Sandwiches

A plastic storage container filled with rows of sandwich cookies with white and pink cream fillings.
tomatopastesz – Reddit

Unlike the vast majority of items in this list, these sandwiches aren’t savory. Reddit user tomatopastesz’s post reveals sugar cookie sandwiches filled with fresh lemon buttercream and strawberry buttercream. He also mentioned using two sticks of softened, unsalted butter, 1 1/3 cups of sugar, 1 large egg, 2 teaspoons of vanilla extract, 2 1/2 cups of all-purpose flour, 1/2 teaspoon of baking powder, 1/2 teaspoon of baking soda and 1/2 teaspoon of salt.

Egg in Hole, Bacon and Cheese Sandwich

A stacked breakfast sandwich made with toasted bread, fried eggs, and bacon on a plate.
sgarner0407 – Reddit

Reddit user sgarner0407, who prepared this sandwich, mentioned that it’s a life-changing meal, an exaggeration, of course, but meant to convey just how delicious this sandwich was. A comment from user Chairman_Mittens noted: “Thanks for this idea stranger, I’ve been eating egg in the hole on its own but not like that.”

Bacon, Cheese and Ghost Pepper Sandwich with Creamy Tomato Basil Soup

A bowl of creamy tomato soup served with a grilled ham and cheese sandwich cut in half.
sc1f1wasab1 – Reddit

Reddit user sc1f1wasab1 combined one of these homemade sandwiches with soup to create a filling lunch. He mentioned that having an immersion blender made preparing the soup easier, and that he bought the sandwich ingredients at a local grocery store near his home. Finally, he noted that the very spicy flavor paired perfectly with the bacon.

Grilled Mac n’ Cheese Sandwich

Two halves of a grilled macaroni and cheese sandwich stacked on a white plate, one of these homemade sandwiches.
[borrado] – Reddit

One of the most unusual examples of homemade sandwiches on this list is the grilled Mac and cheese sandwich shared by Reddit user [borrado]. Some commenters, such as doubleflusher, noted that it involves combining carbohydrates with carbohydrates. Meanwhile, another user, spectrearrow, suggested adding honey to the sandwich to enhance the flavor.

Biscuit Sandiwch

A biscuit breakfast sandwich with a fried egg, bacon, and spinach.
ajp12290 – Reddit

The biscuit sandwich is made with bacon, eggs, mozzarella, and spinach. Reddit user ajp12290 made sure the sandwich contained at least two eggs, knowing that one of them would fall apart the moment he took the first bite. Also, he mentioned preferring liquid over custard on the sandwich when the bread needs something to soak up.

Pot Roast Sandwich

A sliced roast beef sandwich on a toasted, herb-crusted hoagie roll on a wooden cutting board.
Lucy_Koshka – Reddit

According to Reddit user Lucy_Koshka, one of these homemade sandwiches was made with pot roast, Gruyère, Swiss, and Brie cheeses, and caramelized onions. The user also mentioned feeling like he had forgotten an ingredient, which, as he confessed in the comments, was horseradish.

Smoked Pork Shoulder Cuban Sandwich

A toasted Cuban sandwich cut in half, revealing layers of ham, roasted pork, swiss cheese, and pickles.
Liquidgrin1781 – Reddit

The image shows a Cuban sandwich containing smoked pork shoulder, cooked for 14 hours, combined with Black Forest ham, house-cured sour dill pickles, Carolina mustard barbecue sauce, Swiss cheese, and some nicely pressed French bread. User monkeysareeverywhere commented: “This sandwich looks and sounds delicious, but it’s a stretch to call it a cuban,” because there was none cuban bread involved.

Brioche Breakfast Sandwich

A hand holding a toasted breakfast sandwich stacked in two halves, featuring scrambled eggs, bacon, and a creamy herb sauce.
Josh_Elkin – Reddit

The versatility of homemade sandwiches allows them to serve as lunch, dinner, or even breakfast, the latter being the case for Reddit user Josh_Elkin. The cook described the sandwich’s layers as brioche bread, cream cheese with chives, eggs, bacon, another layer of cream cheese with chives, mascarpone cheese, and a final slice of brioche bread.

Double Chicken Sandwich

A hand holding a double fried chicken sandwich with melted cheese, lettuce, pickles, and sauce on a bun.
Yosef_kh – Reddit

Reddit user Yosef_kh revealed that preparing one of these homemade sandwiches isn’t that complicated, it just requires the person to have a look into double dredging techniques and find a proper chicken breading recipe, such as flour, cornstarch, spices and baking powder. User melanthius commented: “Frying at home is daunting, it’s very difficult to maintain the correct oil temperature on a regular stove even if you’re diligent about measuring it.”

Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich

Fried chicken sandwich on toasted bread with lettuce, pickles, and sauce.
ianjmcg – Reddit

Reddit user ianjmcg revealed that one of these homemade sandwiches has been a food staple in Nashville since the 1930s. The Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich has, in fact, driven the emergence of imitations at other fast-food spots, such as ‘Howlin’ Ray’s’, over the last 3 to 4 years, according to the user. In addition, the user mimicked that sandwich, but the craze has since become a full-blown trend at restaurants in Los Angeles.

Bacon, Spinach, Avocado, Goat Cheese, and Tomato Sandwich

A grilled sandwich cut in half, filled with bacon, avocado, and greens on toasted bread.
lurker_mcderpleson – Reddit

One of these homemade sandwiches has a unique feature, the bacon is pre-cooked in an oven at 425 degrees for 15 minutes, according to Reddit user lurker_mcderpleson. Additionally, the user mentioned: “While that’s going on, I cook down the spinach, slice the tomato and avocado and fry the bread in a bit of butter right before the bacon is ready.”

Conclusion

A woman in a yellow shirt prepares to take a bite of a sandwich at a wooden dining table.
DjelicS – istockphoto

These homemade sandwiches are every bit as good as those prepared in specialty shops. When you make your own sandwich, whether it’s one with fried chicken or perhaps something with spinach, meat, and cheddar, you can experiment with any combination you like, creating a whole new flavor experience for your palate.