Christmas morning looked a little different for kids growing up in the 1950s, ’60s, and early ’70s. Long before stockings were stuffed with expensive electronics, gift cards, and fancy beauty products, Christmas stocking stuffers for Boomers were often as simple as a handful of candy, a small toy, or even a fresh orange waiting by the fireplace. And while the biggest presents usually sat wrapped beneath the Christmas tree, there was something especially exciting about reaching into a stocking to see what Santa had left behind.
Of course, not every family filled stockings the same way. Some parents stuck to traditional treats like nuts and fruit, while others picked up inexpensive surprises from the local five-and-dime. Either way, the fun was often in the little things: a brand-new box of crayons, a toy car small enough to fit in your pocket, or a few coins you could spend however you pleased.
From Silly Putty eggs to candy canes and colorful marbles, here are 12 classic Christmas stocking stuffers that might bring back memories for Baby Boomers.
A Big Orange at the Very Bottom
For generations, finding an orange at the bottom of your Christmas stocking was practically a holiday tradition. Although fresh citrus became easier to find throughout the year during the 20th century, many families continued the custom of tucking an orange or tangerine into the toe of each stocking.
And if you remember reaching inside and feeling something surprisingly heavy, chances are it was that orange. Some kids might have preferred another piece of candy, but the fruit was often just as much a part of Christmas morning as the presents under the tree.
Mixed Nuts Still in Their Shells
Before individually packaged snacks became such a convenient option, Christmas stockings sometimes contained a handful of walnuts, pecans, almonds, or Brazil nuts. They weren’t exactly ready to eat, either. You needed a nutcracker, a little patience, and sometimes a second attempt to get through those stubborn shells.
Many Boomer households also kept a bowl of mixed nuts on the coffee table throughout the holiday season, usually accompanied by a metal nutcracker. Between the orange and the nuts, the bottom of a Christmas stocking could feel surprisingly heavy.
Candy Canes and Individually Wrapped Christmas Candy
No Christmas stocking was complete without something sweet. Candy canes were a particularly popular choice because they were inexpensive, festive, and easy to tuck inside a stocking. Sometimes the curved end even stuck out over the top, offering a little preview of what Santa had brought.
Other familiar treats included peppermints, assorted hard candies, and individually wrapped chocolates. And while kids today might expect an entire assortment of their favorite sweets, a few carefully chosen pieces of candy could make Christmas morning feel pretty special back then.
Silly Putty in Its Little Plastic Egg
Few stocking stuffers were as wonderfully strange as Silly Putty. Packaged in its familiar plastic egg, this stretchy, bouncy substance became a childhood favorite during the 1950s and ’60s. Kids could roll it into a ball, flatten it against the table, or stretch it into ridiculous shapes.
But the real magic happened when you pressed it against the newspaper comics and watched the pictures transfer onto the putty. It was the kind of simple trick that could keep a child entertained for hours, even if the novelty eventually ended up stuck to the carpet.
A Tiny Matchbox or Hot Wheels Car
For kids who loved toy cars, finding a miniature vehicle inside their Christmas stocking was a pretty exciting discovery. Matchbox cars became popular during the 1950s, while Mattel introduced Hot Wheels in 1968, giving younger Boomers another collection of tiny vehicles to obsess over.
And you didn’t need an elaborate racetrack to have fun with them. A kitchen floor, the arm of a sofa, or a few wooden blocks could become an entire imaginary highway. Of course, the best part was showing off your newest car to your friends and comparing whose collection was bigger.
Trending on Cheapism
A Yo-Yo That Might Last for Years
A yo-yo might not have looked like much when you pulled it out of your stocking, but it could provide months of entertainment. Duncan yo-yos were especially recognizable, and children spent countless afternoons practicing tricks like Walk the Dog and Around the World.
The challenge was getting good enough to impress your friends. Schoolyard competitions and neighborhood demonstrations were part of the fun, and a particularly talented kid could make an ordinary yo-yo look almost magical. Not bad for a toy that didn’t need batteries.
A Small Bag of Marbles or a Set of Jacks
Sometimes the smallest stocking stuffers turned out to be the most entertaining. A little bag of colorful glass marbles or a set of metal jacks could keep children busy long after the wrapping paper had been cleared away.
Marbles were especially fun to collect, with their swirling colors and distinctive patterns making certain ones more desirable than others. Jacks, meanwhile, required quick reflexes and plenty of practice. Both were perfect for playing with friends on the sidewalk, in the schoolyard, or across the living-room floor.
A Fresh Box of Crayons or Colored Pencils
There was something irresistible about opening a brand-new box of crayons on Christmas morning. The colors were perfectly arranged, the tips hadn’t been worn down, and that unmistakable waxy smell practically invited you to start drawing.
For many Boomer kids, a fresh box of Crayola crayons was a practical but exciting stocking gift, especially if it contained more colors than the small assortment they used at school. Add a coloring book or a stack of blank paper, and you had enough entertainment to get through a good portion of Christmas vacation.
Sign up for our newsletter
A Miniature Puzzle, Card Game, or Deck of Playing Cards
Not every Christmas stocking surprise was meant to be enjoyed alone. Small decks of playing cards, miniature puzzles, and inexpensive card games were easy to find at five-and-dime stores and made practical gifts for children.
Games like Old Maid and Go Fish were especially familiar, and a new deck could quickly turn into an afternoon of competition with siblings or cousins. Best of all, these games didn’t require much space, making them perfect for bringing along to Grandma’s house during the holidays.
A Comic Book or Small Activity Book
For children who loved reading, a comic book tucked into their stocking could be just as exciting as a new toy. During the 1950s and ’60s, kids could find plenty of inexpensive comics featuring superheroes, funny animals, and familiar cartoon characters.
Small puzzle books, coloring pads, and activity books were other popular possibilities. And because they were easy to enjoy immediately, some children probably started flipping through their new comics before they even finished opening the larger presents under the tree.
A Slinky or Another Small Spring Toy
The Slinky had already become a toy-store favorite by the time many Boomers were growing up, and its simple design made it a memorable Christmas gift. After all, what could be more entertaining than watching a metal spring seemingly walk down a flight of stairs?
Of course, getting it to perform properly wasn’t always as easy as the commercials made it look. Sometimes it stopped halfway down, and other times it became a hopelessly tangled mess. But when it worked, the distinctive sound of that metal spring tumbling down wooden steps was part of the magic.
A Few Coins, Sometimes Chocolate Ones
Sometimes the most exciting thing hiding at the bottom of a Christmas stocking was money. A few coins or a small bill might not sound like much today, but for a child growing up in the 1950s or ’60s, it could mean a trip to the candy counter or the neighborhood five-and-dime.
Chocolate coins wrapped in shiny gold foil were another familiar stocking treat, connecting the tradition to the legend of Saint Nicholas leaving gold for a family in need. Whether the coins were real or made of chocolate, discovering them inside your stocking always felt like finding a little treasure.
When Christmas Stockings Were Full of Simple Surprises
Looking back, it’s remarkable how much excitement could come from such inexpensive gifts. An orange, a handful of nuts, a little toy car, or a fresh box of crayons might not seem particularly impressive by today’s standards, but for many Boomers, those small surprises were an unforgettable part of Christmas morning.
And the best part? Most of these classic stocking stuffers are still around today. Whether you’re filling stockings for your grandchildren or simply feeling nostalgic for Christmases past, there’s something wonderful about remembering a time when the simplest gifts could bring the biggest smiles.
