Cheapism is editorially independent. We may earn a commission if you buy through links on our site.

On the left, baked beans are poured over whole carrots—a classic example of funny cooking fails. On the right, a hand holds a slice of bread spread with greenish jelly, with a similar slice on a plate below.
Reddit

When you get ready to cook, you have the final dish in mind and start savoring the flavors the moment you mix the first ingredients. However, things don’t always go smoothly in the kitchen, and you might run into a few mishaps. These Reddit users shared the funny cooking fails they experienced! Buckle up, folks.

Bad Case of Pizzeria

A frozen tart box shows how it should look, but in the oven, the crust collapsed, and toppings spilled onto the rack and oven floor, with burnt cheese and tomatoes scattered below.
EdgarBopp – Reddit

Reddit user EdgarBopp mentioned: “Of course I’ve been cooking frozen pizzas my whole adult life and I know how to preheat an oven. The pizza was frozen.” One reply from user Gummymyers124 pointed out that you have to put the pizza on a tray, and in the box they recommend to put the pizza on the middle rack, but no one trust that during funny cooking fails.

Not Intended Jalebi

A plate of bright orange jalebi on the left and a plate of brownish jalebi on the right, both are Indian sweet desserts with a spiral shape.
[borrado] – Reddit

Reddit user [borrado] expressed that he intended to make Jalebi, an Indian dessert that is supposed to look like the one on the left. But he created the disaster on the right in one of his funny cooking fails. He commented that it was his first attempt on this dessert and he will try to make it better the next time. Nevertheless, he mentioned that despite the shape although it doesn’t look appealing, it actually tasted great and crispy.

Baja Blast Sauce

A hand holds a slice of toast topped with a greenish spread; another piece with the same spread is on a black plate below. A bread bag is partially visible in the background.
Zak_the_Wack – Reddit

Reddit user Zak_the_Wack mentioned that he tried to make a Baja blast sauce, that is a real, limited-edition condiment made by Mountain Dew in partnership with the Houston hot sauce shop iBurn but it got a jelly consistency. He also added that putting the sauce on bread was an idea of a friend of his, making it one of his funny cooking fails, and he defended his actions by stating that the food cannot evolve without people willing to experiment.

Lemon Peel Candy

Side-by-side image: left, yellow candied fruit peels coated in sugar; right, glossy dark brown candied fruit peels on parchment paper.
AWorthlessDegenerate – Reddit

Reddit user AWorthlessDegenerate revealed that the problem in the process was to add not enough sugar and too much water to the mix. The greatly lengthened the cooking time and resulted in the picture on the right, another example of funny cooking fails. One reply from user MunchYourBut mentioned: “It looks like a sugar octopus.”

$710 Wedding Cake

A four-tiered naked cake with white frosting and yellow fruit slices, possibly mango, is displayed on a table. People in formal attire are visible in the background.
stekene – Reddit

At a wedding in Belgium, the newlyweds commissioned a baker to make the reception cake, as is done in much of the world, and this is what they got. The fruit-themed cake, which cost $710, looked like something a child had made for a school project, making it one of the most expensive funny cooking fails. Reddit user Consistent-Stock6872 commented: “It looks like the baker let their 15-years-old kid make the cake and then just shrugged ‘good enough’. This isn’t worth even $100.”

First Time Cooking Fish

Cooked, broken pieces of white fish are scattered on a ridged grill pan. The fish appears flaky and slightly browned in spots, covering one side of the pan while the other side is mostly empty.
[borrado] – Reddit

Reddit user [borrado] revealed that his girlfriend told him it was the first time she cooked fish so she made it scrambled. One reply from Reddit user PlanetMidnight mentioned: “We actually make this purposefully in my family and call it ‘fish hash’. Even funny cooking fails can become family traditions. You have to keep crisping the fish in the pan and you’ll have brown bits and flavor with onion or garlic powder and toss it with brown wild rice you previously cooked with chicken stock.”

Two Cooking Class Groups

Two metal pans of cinnamon rolls in an oven: the top image shows them before baking, while the bottom image shows them risen and golden after baking.
[borrado] – Reddit

Reddit user [borrado] revealed that his school cooking class has two groups, and one is much better at cooking than the other as these images exhibit. He also mentioned that food can look like that, not that appetizing but it could taste really good. This comparison perfectly illustrated funny cooking fails. Finally, he pointed out that attention to detail and following the recipe is the main thing that’s lacking in the bottom photo.

Chewbacca Pizza

A pizza decorated to look like Chewbacca from Star Wars, using strips of bacon for fur and sliced black olives for eyes, nose, and a bandolier across the body.
in2diep – Reddit

Reddit user in2diep commented that she saw a Chewbacca pizza on a Facebook cooking group so she decided to give it a try. The result became one of those unforgettable funny cooking fails. That combination of bacon, olives and the supposed Chewbacca shape bears no resemblance to George Lucas’s character. One reply from user chrmanyaki mentioned: “That must taste like eating a jar of salt.”

Trying to Bake

Top: Perfectly sliced yellow cake rolls with cream swirl. Bottom: Crumbled, messy, greenish cake with uneven texture on a plate.
akenstandlosing – Reddit

Reddit user akenstandlosing tried to cook some Swiss rolls that can be very difficult to get right according to some experienced cooks. The outcome joined the list of memorable funny cooking fails. Nevertheless, some users couldn’t understand why they turned out so liquid. One reply from user birbscape90 was a sarcastic one: “I was thinking of baking a cake soon, this has inspired me.”

Bamboozled by the Pretzels

Photo shows a box of cheddar-filled pretzel bites with an image of golden, cheesy pretzel snacks. Below, the actual cooked pretzel bites appear darker, cracked, and less appetizing than the picture on the box.
Ieggymacaroni – Reddit

Reddit user Ieggymacaroni revealed that although they needed more salt, those pretzels tasted pretty good although they didn’t look very appetizing. Still, they qualify as funny cooking fails. He also added: “I think the problem is that we cooked them for 15 minutes instead of the 7 to 10 minutes I believe they should be cooked.”

One of Two Attempts to Cook Pizza

A person holds a pizza paddle with a heavily burnt pepperoni pizza, featuring blackened crust and melted cheese, on a rustic wooden table.
nancyexe – Reddit

Reddit user nancyexe mentioned that her friend cooked with a pizza oven at a temperature that was far too high and she thinks it’s made for raw dough and not for just a frozen pizza from a box. It became another entry in the collection of funny cooking fails. A reply from casual_42 mentioned: “At this rate, attempt number 3 might graduate from charcoal to edible!”

Not Perfectly Cooked Chicken

Sliced grilled chicken breast with visible pink, undercooked centers on a white plate, set on a granite countertop. The seasoning is visible on the surface of the meat.
matthproject – Reddit

Reddit user matthproject revealed that this chicken was cooked by her husband. And also, he told her: “It’s perfectly cooked.” Despite his confidence, it quickly became one of the thread’s most shocking funny cooking fails. Some replies like the one from user Stickey_Rickey mentioned: “Because salmonella lives on the outside of chicken, the exposed parts, it’s ok to undercook it but just a tiny bit. That is not edible, I don’t feel well after looking at it.”

The Steak My Brother Cooked Me

A close-up of a piece of beef steak cut in half on a white plate, showing a mostly raw, red interior. A fork and knife are placed next to the steak.
Makewayfornoodynoody – Reddit

Reddit user makewayfornoodynoody mentioned his brother cooked this meat from a local co-op in a cast iron pan and he had to recook it so to get it edible. It was another of his early funny cooking fails. He also mentioned that his brother was 17 years old and trying to learn cooking because he was going to college the following year.

Burned Tots

A baking sheet with several severely burnt tater tots scattered across it, all blackened and charred beyond recognition.
NumberOneSeinfeldFan – Reddit

Reddit user NumberOneSeinfeldFan revealed that he returned to his house and discovered it was very smoky in there. When he knocked on his brother’s door asking if he was cooking something he heard him pause and remembered what he was doing. Those tots became one of the most unforgettable funny cooking fails when they turned into charcoal. Reddit user johandepohan replied: “That’s one way to burn calories.”

Trying to Eat More Vegetables

Whole baby carrots topped with baked beans are arranged on a sheet of parchment paper, ready for preparation or serving.
notbobbybob – Reddit

Reddit user notbobbybob mentioned that her sister is trying to eat more vegetables while she learns how to cook them. The unusual recipe turned into one of her funny cooking fails. She also revealed that she came up with this recipe in her head and went for it. It’s canned baked beans with carrots that along with rice, egg white and giant chunks of yam in a rice cooker that didn’t cook all of it.

The Sauce of the Lasagna Evaporated

Three pieces of lasagna with visible meat sauce and cheese are served on a white plate with a blue rim, sitting on a counter.
Jusko892 – Reddit

Reddit user Jusko892 commented that he tried to cook lasagna but he discovered that the sauce evaporated once he got the plate from the oven. One reply from 6BigZ6 mentioned: “That’s called boiling, and the sauce was water. Maybe he missed a few crucial steps somewhere.”

Chicken, Mushroom and Oats

A bowl of oatmeal mixed with chunks of chicken and sliced mushrooms, with metal chopsticks resting inside. The bowl is placed on a black surface in front of a computer keyboard.
frogfoot11 – Reddit

Reddit user frogfoot11 mentioned his friends cooked this dish that seemed to be one that looked like Frankenstein’s monster, assembled from scraps. But Reddit user Jiggylera commented: “This looks completely unappetizing and disgusting. Why would someone prepare it like this, just put the oats in a separate bowl with that. And also the mushrooms are so big.”

New Pasta vs Old Pasta

A solid block of frozen sauce sits on top of cooked rotini pasta in a pot on a stovetop. An empty plastic container is nearby.
the-redcstone – Reddit

Reddit user the-redcstone remembered when his 22-years-old brother decided to cook and put the Tupperware of frozen pasta sauce directly onto the already cooked pasta when neither of them made enough money to order takeaway. He added: “It made that sort of scraping sound that frozen Tupperware makes when you take it out of the freezer and then a soft plop.”

Forgot The Pizza

A frozen Red Baron pizza is overcooked, with a very burnt top and edges, still on its packaging, sitting on a kitchen counter near spices, salt and pepper shakers, and a pot on the stove.
[borrado] – Reddit

Reddit user [borrado] mentioned he would love to say he forgot about the pizza, but this time he commented he didn’t hear the timer go off. He also added: “I think if I put some parmesan cheese on top of it, it would be good, but I don’t recommend looking at it directly. Other than the crust it was somehow tasty.”

Chicken Breast Like Winter Mitten

Two cooked chicken breasts with sauce in a black frying pan on a stovetop, with some bubbling sauce around the meat.
E3galloway – Reddit

Reddit user E3galloway mentioned that he tried to cook a chicken breast that looked like a winter mitten, and when he tasted it was as dry as one too. He revealed the sauce was overcooked barbecue sauced diluted with water and also commented: “I ate 100% of it surprisingly and I became really obsessed with gloves afterwards, so far about 7 pairs and counting.”

Conclusion

Chicken pieces cooking on a grill with bright flames and smoke rising up around them, creating a sizzling and intense barbecue scene.
edb3_16 – istockphoto

Chicken is a great food to start with when learning to cook, given the variety of dishes you can make with it. But if your dishes end up looking like these, even if barely edible and hilarious, don’t worry, you’ll improve over time while having a laugh along the way. It’s happened to all of us.