Homemade Thanksgiving foods can be just as memorable as the holiday itself, especially when home cooks put their own spin on the classics. From carefully roasted turkeys and towering pie spreads to creative sides, international twists, and dinners made for just two, these Reddit photos show how much effort and personality can go into a Thanksgiving feast.
This Thanksgiving Turkey Took Years to Perfect
This home cook shared a beautifully plated Thanksgiving turkey after spending more than a decade refining the recipe. The bird was broken down, dry-brined, roasted, grilled, or cooked sous vide before being carefully arranged for serving. Reddit user onerichmeyer praised the impressive plating and presentation.
This Practice Turkey Looked Ready for the Real Thanksgiving
Instead of waiting for Thanksgiving Day, this home cook held a dress rehearsal with a turkey brined overnight, stuffed with spicy sausage and mushroom stuffing, and roasted until deeply browned. The cook said the bird stayed moist throughout. Reddit user Branmanicus joked that no more practice was needed because the turkey already looked beautiful.
This Thanksgiving Dinner Turned Turkey Into Meatballs
Instead of serving a whole bird, this Canadian Thanksgiving spread featured turkey and stuffing meatballs alongside loaded mashed potatoes, honey-dill carrots, green beans, gravy, and cranberry sauce. The bite-sized meatballs were apparently a major hit. Reddit user paulerxx suggested turning them into a sandwich layered with mashed potatoes and gravy.
This Thanksgiving Feast Brought a Taste of Home to Korea
An American living in Korea recreated a Thanksgiving dinner using what was available locally, even swapping turkey for chicken and making sweet potato casserole with Korean sweet potatoes. The spread also included mac and cheese, which sparked plenty of discussion. Reddit user Corey307 said that “I don’t see an attempt, I see a proper Thanksgiving dinner.”
This Entire Thanksgiving Feast Was Made From Scratch
This Canadian Thanksgiving spread took two full days of cooking and preparation, with every dish made from scratch. The effort showed in a table packed with classic holiday favorites and enough food to make commenters tired just looking at it. Reddit user ipso-factor summed up the scale perfectly, saying, “I’m exhausted just looking.”
Trending on Cheapism
This Thanksgiving Dinner for Two Focused on Their Favorites
For their second Thanksgiving together, this couple skipped the oversized menu and made only the dishes they loved most, including collard greens and homemade mac and cheese. The cozy spread still impressed Reddit. User I_Luv_Adobo said, “I just finished eating, saw your post, and now I’m hungry again.”
This Thanksgiving Dinner Became a Cooking Time Capsule
This home cook looked back at a Thanksgiving dinner from 2020 and admitted they once considered it the height of their cooking skills. Years later, the photo became a fun reminder of how much they had improved. Reddit user reddfawks said the meal made them feel nostalgic for an old Toronto restaurant that served similar turkey dinners.
This Danish Cook Nailed Thanksgiving Without Using Recipes
A home cook in Denmark made a Thanksgiving-inspired dinner despite never having tasted several of the holiday staples before. The homemade spread included stuffed turkey roast, cranberry sauce, sweet potato mash, potato salad, and three-bean salad. Reddit user riddus praised the effort, saying, “I’d say you did great.”
Sign up for our newsletter
This First Thanksgiving Feast Nailed the Comfort Food
For a first attempt at making Thanksgiving dinner, this home cook put together a hearty spread featuring smoked Honey-Cajun ham, honey-glazed rainbow carrots, Tini’s mac and cheese, green bean casserole, and smoked Yukon mashed potatoes. Reddit user joao_lopesr praised how juicy the meat looked and congratulated the cook on the impressive meal.
This Thanksgiving Spread Mixed Traditions at the Table
This homemade feast included turkey, stuffing, mac and cheese, green bean casserole, twice-baked potatoes, bread, cranberry sauce with orange and cinnamon, and fried rice added for the cook’s West Indian in-laws. The generous spread quickly won over commenters. Reddit user TinySoftKitten asked, “Can I come? That looks amazing.”
This Thanksgiving Plate Had Gravy Worth Talking About
This homemade Thanksgiving plate brought together the comforting holiday classics, including turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, cranberry sauce, and plenty of rich gravy. The presentation had Reddit users admiring the meal before Thanksgiving even arrived. Reddit user Alma singled out one detail, saying, “That gravy looks decadent in all the right ways.”
This Thanksgiving Feast Fed a Crowd of 30
Cooking Thanksgiving dinner for 30 meant going big, with three fried turkeys plus casseroles, stuffing, mashed potatoes, gravy, mac and cheese, deviled eggs, soup, and plenty of appetizers. The cook spent about seven hours prepping the night before and another four cooking. Reddit user georgstgeegland said, “Everything looks absolutely sublime.”
This Thanksgiving Spread Went Way Beyond Turkey
This homemade feast paired the traditional turkey with salmon, Filipino-style cebuchon, and plenty of sides and desserts. The salmon was finished with a lemon-caper-dill cream sauce, while dessert included Biscoff banana pudding and brown butter apple blondies. Reddit user coco9882 praised the presentation, saying the turkey platter looked especially appetizing.
This British Cook Took On a Full Thanksgiving Feast
A British home cook tried making Thanksgiving dinner for the first time, serving turkey with red cabbage, Brussels sprouts gratin, mac and cheese, stuffing, mashed potatoes, homemade buns, and green bean casserole. The effort earned plenty of praise. Reddit user GoinWithThePhloem said, “I LOVE the mashed potato presentation. You did an amazing job all around.”
This Thanksgiving Dinner Kept Things Classic and Cozy
This homemade Thanksgiving dinner featured the kind of comforting spread that makes the holiday feel complete. The simple presentation let the food do the talking and showed that an impressive Thanksgiving meal does not need elaborate plating.
This First Thanksgiving Feast Was Made Just for Two
After learning to cook only about a year earlier, this home cook made a Thanksgiving feast for herself and her boyfriend featuring pineapple-glazed ham, baked mac and cheese, bacon Brussels sprouts, mashed potatoes, candied yams, and jalapeno cheddar cornbread. Reddit user Original-Strain called it “the most aesthetic TG plate ever.”
This First Thanksgiving Dinner Earned Plenty of Praise
For a first attempt at cooking Thanksgiving dinner, this homemade spread came out looking impressively polished and comforting. The meal drew a string of enthusiastic reactions from fellow food lovers, with several commenters congratulating the cook on the result. Reddit user raphtze said, “everything looks awesome 🙂 happy thanksgiving!”
This Thanksgiving Meal Swapped Turkey for Roast Beef
Not everyone wants turkey on Thanksgiving, and this homemade meal proved the holiday can still feel festive without it. The cook prepared roast beef for a dinner shared with his girlfriend, alongside mac and cheese, gravy, and other comforting sides. Reddit user nijonas12 singled out one favorite, saying, “Mac and cheese on point.”
This Baker Made 50 Thanksgiving Pies From Scratch
One ambitious baker turned the day before Thanksgiving into “Pie Day”, making about 50 pies for friends and family who covered the ingredient costs. The huge spread included cheesecakes and traditional pies, with homemade crusts prepared ahead and frozen. Reddit user nunyabuziness said they wanted recipes for every pie and called the entire display amazing.
This Last-Minute Thanksgiving Dinner Came Together in the Netherlands
An American living in the Netherlands pulled together a last-minute Thanksgiving dinner for two with chicken legs, cranberry sauce, Brussels sprout salad, pumpkin pie, and sausage, bacon, apple, and fennel stuffing. The cook said sourcing some American ingredients abroad can be tricky. Reddit user sweetandspicyyy222 was especially interested in the pumpkin pie recipe.
