Cheapism is editorially independent. We may earn a commission if you buy through links on our site.

Two unusual foods showcasing weird food combinations: On the left, a slice of rare steak coated in white icing and rainbow sprinkles. On the right, a sandwich roll with a large strawberry inside instead of meat.
Reddit

Since most people enjoy eating, food is a part of their daily lives. Whether they are cooking, ordering takeout, or shopping at the grocery store, they are often thinking about the next delicious or unique dish they’ll get to savor. Sometimes, however, they encounter weird food combinations where food takes center stage, and end up posting these strange images on Reddit!

Food Storage

Three half-eaten burgers and sandwiches are stuck underneath a wooden table, with various objects and signs visible in the blurred background.
SnooKiwis8540 – Reddit

Reddit user SnooKiwis8540 revealed that he had been stuffing food under a co-worker’s table for a few months so his area would stink. You can see a bagel, bread, pizza, and what it looks like a chocolate cream cookie in the background. User yooq2 replied: “There’s something vaguely threatening about how large and obvious the food items are.”

The Mysterious Food on Porch

A small jar with a red lid sits on a low wall at night, overlooking an empty street with orange traffic barrels and a yellow house in the background.
sunniestgirl – Reddit

Reddit user sunniestgirl revealed that she kept finding random food on her front porch where she lives in downtown Sarasota, Florida, but she didn’t know why it happened. Also, she expressed that the items she found, like a Tupperware container, were opened and had obviously been eaten from. Finally, she mentioned that she has a Ring app, but it wasn’t working at that time.

Cereal Frozen Cubes

An ice cube tray filled with SpaghettiOs is shown; on the right, a glass of water has two SpaghettiOs “ice cubes” floating inside.
zzBeds – Reddit

We don’t understand why anyone would go to the trouble of freezing pasta with sauce and then adding it to a glass of water. Even if you were a huge pasta fan, you wouldn’t end up with a similar flavor, quite the opposite.

Banana Hot Dog

A banana in a hot dog bun is topped with ketchup next to a regular hot dog in a bun, also with ketchup.
zzBeds – Reddit

The only explanation we can find for this banana inside a hot dog bun is that a friend wanted to play a prank on another, so he prepared one regular hot dog with a sausage and another with a banana and ketchup on top. Just thinking about the flavor combination is strange enough as it is. Just thinking about these weird food combinations is strange enough as it is.

Young Adult Doesn’t Use the Last of Anything

Three open tubs of Philadelphia cream cheese are shown on a surface, each partially empty with uneven scoops taken from the inside. The silver lids are peeled back and resting on top of each container.
kiwidust – Reddit

Reddit user kiwidust revealed she has a son who, when he was 14 years old, never used the products until they were completely finished. She added: “This is Philadelphia cream cheese and I rarely use it. Apparently he doesn’t enjoy cleaning up containers for recycling and that’s the cause of this situation.” Even weird food combinations can start this way.

Apple Pie with Cheddar Crust

Left: Unbaked pie with intricate floral and geometric crust design, dusted with colorful powder. Right: Open pie with sliced apples mixed with cinnamon inside a pie crust.
cakepiecake – Reddit

No, we haven’t made a mistake, this user shared an image showing an apple pie prepared with cheddar cheese around the edges. Cakepiecake revealed that it wasn’t an overly sweet dish, made with fresh apples from a tree near her home in Toronto. She also added: “It took me nearly half a day to make but probably you can buy something like this from a professional bakery.”

Weird Look Burger

A black sesame burger bun filled with octopus tentacles, fried onions, tomatoes, asparagus, diced potatoes, and creamy sauce, held in hand on a city street.
devilsdontcry – Reddit

It’s impossible to maintain any sense of decorum while eating this burger, featuring octopus, asparagus, potatoes, cream, caramelized onion, and tomato. Especially given the octopus elasticity, which makes it difficult to eat without the other ingredients falling out. A mess is inevitable with weird food combinations like this.

Banana with Panera Sauce

A mug filled with thick, dark stew or chili, with half of a peeled banana placed inside. The mug is on a surface covered by a pink and white floral-patterned fabric.
EyeSimp4Asuka – Reddit

A Reddit user revealed that a colleague once spent $100 on Panera sauce, which she put on sandwiches and soup, yet still had plenty left over. One day, she found her eating a banana dipped in the sauce. She revealed that although it was a shock at first, upon tasting it, she discovered a savory flavor, much like eating plantains with stew. It’s another example of weird food combinations.

Pi Pie

Unbaked berry pie topped with a braided crust edge and a large crust cutout shaped like the mathematical pi symbol in the center. The pie sits on a wooden surface.

The famous mathematical number Pi, which equals 3,14149… and continues infinitely without repeating, is the distance around a circle divided by the straight line across its middle, but it is also the symbol that appears on this pie. Reddit user CantaloupeClassic687 made this blueberry dish and was about to toss it into the oven.

Tostinos with Barbecue Sauce

Hand holding a pizza snack dipped in barbecue sauce on a plate; more pizza snacks and a bottle of Sweet Baby Ray’s Barbecue Sauce are nearby on a white cutting board and stove.
fle_xx – Reddit

Reddit user fle_xx revealed this photo when he ate Tostinos with barbecue sauce. Those corn tortilla chips are delicious snacks and are often served at parties with dips like melted cheese or guacamole. But surely, few people would have thought of these weird food combinations, dipping them in barbecue sauce.

Honey and Serrano Hot Sauce on Pepperoni Pizza

A plate with a slice of pepperoni pizza sits on a wooden table. Nearby are bottles of organic raw honey and Yellowbird Serrano hot sauce.
drewnyp – Reddit

Reddit user drewnyp revealed that he tossed some honey and Serrano hot sauce on pepperoni pizza and it tasted delicious. User NationalElephantDay commented that hot sauce on pizza is standard in Seattle. But what makes us unsure about these weird food combinations is that both the hot sauce and the pepperoni have a strong taste, and the honey might tone it down. It’s a real dilemma, how it actually tastes.

Pickles with Milk

A hand dips a pickle into a clear glass filled with milk, set on a brown surface.
zzBeds – Reddit

There are dishes that combine pickles and milk, or at least pickle juice. One of these weird food combinations is Dill Pickle Soup from Poland, made with diced or grated dill pickles, potato, broth, and finished with a splash of milk or sour cream to get a creamy texture. But we are sure that this photo does not represent any of it. The person involved in the photo simply has odd tastes.

Banana and Chips

A hand holds a banana slice with cereal flakes pressed into it over a white paper plate containing more banana and cereal pieces.
admin_NLboy – Reddit

Reddit user admin_NLboy revealed this photo of him eating a banana with chips while some users replied: “It would maybe be better if you smashed the banana first and used it more like a sauce.” However, a combination of chips and banana doesn’t seem appealing to us in any of those ways; but since we haven’t tried it, we won’t judge.

Oatmeal with Eggs

Two plastic containers: one holds two fried eggs with crispy edges, the other has a ceramic mug filled with oatmeal and a spoon. Both are set on a white surface.
jumpmannn1 – Reddit

Having oatmeal or scrambled eggs for breakfast is a typical choice for many Americans. However, the same cannot be said for eating both at the same time. These weird food combinations create a pastry-like texture in your mouth, and you will need plenty of liquid to wash them down.

Nori Rolled Spaghetti with Meat Sauce and Takis

A sheet of seaweed topped with spaghetti and several red spicy snack sticks on a wooden surface.
Only_Situation_6120 – Reddit

This dish couldn’t get any weirder. It has a bit of Italian, thanks to the spaghetti, a bit of Mexican cuisine, because of the Takis, and even some Japanese, thanks to the nori. But all together, these weird food combinations look like an aberration. Impossible-Ghost commented: “I would probably crush them up into a seasoning instead of trying to eat it like that but I get what you are going for, spicy spaghetti. It’s interesting.”

Meat Donut

A donut with white icing and colorful sprinkles, but the inside appears to be rare-cooked beef instead of regular donut bread. A bite has been taken out.
zzBeds – Reddit

The problem with many of these foods is that, individually, they are delicious, like this piece of meat and the frosting on top. Frosting belongs on a sweet treat. With this item, you could easily mistake it for a donut. These weird food combinations are a problem in themselves. And in case you think this image is fake, just look at the meat juices underneath.

Hot Dog Bread with Cucumber Sprinkled with Coffee Powder and Mayo

A hot dog bun filled with a slice of cucumber, topped with a generous amount of white cream and a sprinkle of dark powder, resting on a light-colored surface.
Stanleyissomething – Reddit

Reddit user Stanleyissomething commented that he wouldn’t eat a hot dog bun with cucumber sprinkled with some coffee powder and mayonnaise although he said it didn’t taste so bad. We think this user was hungry and didn’t want to go out to buy food or order delivery, so he put together one of these weird food combinations using leftovers from his own fridge.

Strawberry Sandwich

A close-up of a large, ripe strawberry sandwiched between two halves of a soft, golden-brown bread roll, resembling a strawberry burger.
1-800-TYBG – Reddit

It is hard to imagine anyone thinking a strawberry sandwich would taste good. A Reddit user nicknamed this combination ‘Kings Hawaiian,’ though we doubt any restaurant would adopt it as an innovative menu item. The closest thing to one of these weird food combinations is toast with strawberries but it has cream cheese to enhance the flavor and adapt the combination.

Conclusion

A woman in a teal dress lies on the floor next to a pizza box, with a slice of pizza resting on her face near her eyes and mouth.
S_Chum – istockphoto

All these weird food combinations shared on Reddit evoke a mix of surprise and astonishment, often even making you consider trying some of those combinations yourself. You can experiment with food and discover flavors you never expected on your palate.