Fast-food chains no longer sell just hamburgers, fries, and soft drinks. Most chains offer baked goods, such as cookies, biscuits, cinnamon rolls, pastries, and muffins. It’s no secret that not all fast-food baked goods are created equally, though. The value of these items is revealed in Reddit comments from regular customers who have tried them. We highlight some fast-food baked items that are truly delicious, as well as others that failed to win over the clientele.
Chick-fil-A Chocolate Chunk Cookie – Pretty Tasty
Many customers describe Chick-fil-A’s Chocolate Chunk Cookie as one of the best fast-food desserts across the United States. It is soft on the inside and packed with chocolate chunks, and what sets it apart from other cookies is its oat texture. This cookie is so highly regarded that even when customers aren’t in the mood for dessert, they will buy one to enjoy later. Reddit user Ansley_ commented: “I was always an ice cream and a cup person until I tried their cookies. Now I have to get one every time!”
Cinnabon Delights from Taco Bell – Pretty Tasty
One of these bite-sized fast-food desserts has built a loyal following that loves its warm cinnamon filling and cream cheese center. Customers are divided between those who prefer it as a dessert and those who grab it for breakfast; its small size makes it an easy add-on purchase. The consistency maintained over the years ranks it among the best pastries available in the fast-food world. Reddit user SpaceCookiez22 opined: “Can’t beat them when they’re still crispy on the outside and the frosting hasn’t soaked into the bread.”
McDonald’s Baked Apple Pie – Pretty Tasty
The baked version of the McDonald’s Apple Pie stands out as one of the most recognizable fast-food desserts. Fans appreciate its crispy crust and hot apple filling, so much so that it evokes a sense of nostalgia, transporting them back to the past. It is also easy to carry due to its compact size, although customers often buy two pies at a time. Reddit user binob123 opined: “Every time I order one, I think it will just be ‘okay’ but it always ends up tasting amazing. Especially when it’s freshly baked, the texture is perfect.”
Wendy’s Cinnabon Pull-Apart – Pretty Tasty
The Cinnabon Pull-Apart is one of the breakfast options at Wendy’s; thanks to the partnership between Cinnabon and the fast-food chain, it immediately became a standout item in that category. Its soft texture and rich icing set it apart from other cinnamon rolls, and it garners nothing but positive reviews when served warm. Reddit user FrontMachine3789 commented on one of these fast-food desserts: “They’re so good. I get them to add a couple extra squirts of icing on there. I’ve gotten it 3 times this week and I hope they never take it off the menu.”
Popeyes Biscuits – Pretty Tasty
Popeyes biscuits are widely consumed in the United States, despite Internet jokes about how dry they can be. Customers often cite their buttery flavor and flaky layers as their best qualities, with many considering these fast-food desserts an essential accompaniment to fried chicken, while others find them more enjoyable when drizzled with honey or served with jam. Reddit user [borrado] opined: “They are warm, soft, the perfect biscuit and not dry.”
Trending on Cheapism
Arby’s Apple Turnover – Pretty Tasty
Arby’s Apple Turnover is a flaky pastry with apple filling and icing that receives many positive reviews from Arby’s customers. People who enjoy those fast-food desserts often mention that it is highly underrated by individuals who haven’t tried it. Reddit user PlayedUOonBaja reflected: “I’m not really a dessert guy but Arby’s apple and cherry turnovers are pretty awesome. Also their cookies are the best I’ve come across too.”
Starbucks Blueberry Muffin – Needs Work
Flavor isn’t an issue with the Starbucks Blueberry Muffin. However, there are inconsistencies depending on the location, and the price is a common complaint. Many customers describe the size of those fast-food desserts as small, and expectations are high given the premium price; overall, reviews are mixed. Reddit user platypuskenny observed: “I used to eat muffins in two bites when I am stressed, now I can’t eat this bull without butter or something. No quick stress relief anymore.”
Dunkin’ Coffee Cake Muffin – Needs Work
The Dunkin’ Coffee Cake Muffin is best described as convenient but inconsistent, as its freshness varies depending on the day you order it or the specific Dunkin’ location. Furthermore, some customers find those fast-food desserts overly sweet, while others complain that it is dry. Reddit user Lizzle372 revealed: “It’s loaded with sugar as it is, who needs to actively crunch on sugar crystals? It’s so disgusting I cannot do it.”
Sign up for our newsletter
Burger King’s Hershey’s Sundae Pie – Needs Work
Those who have been buying the Burger King Hershey’s Sundae Pie for years largely continue to choose it out of nostalgia, but new customers are not as convinced. Regular customers complain that the texture after thawing has changed and that the portions may be smaller than they were a few years ago; enthusiasm for the dessert seems to have waned. Reddit user prime-mimister commented: “You can likely buy the same exact pie in the grocery store for less. Go to the grocery store and look for Edwards Hershey pies. Same exact thing.”
McDonald’s Chocolate Chip Cookie – Needs Work
Some McDonald’s customers mention that the chocolate chip cookie is inconsistent when baked and that competing cookies outperform it. One positive aspect is that some batches contain a generous amount of chocolate. Reddit user Inn0c3nc3 opined: “I think McDonald’s cookies are trash, but I really miss Otis spunkmeyer cookies.”
Subway Raspberry Cheesecake Cookie – Needs Work
Subway customers do not have a consensus opinion on the company’s raspberry cheesecake cookie; some find it too sweet and note that the texture varies depending on freshness, while others offer positive feedback. To make matters worse, it is not always available at many of the fast-food chain’s locations. Reddit user SpiderCow313 revealed: “At my Subway we really don’t sell cookies a bunch so we always end up with like 10-20 cookies getting thrown out. I usually either give the leftover cookies to someone or take it home so it’s a nice bonus.”
Tim Hortons Muffins – Needs Work
Tim Hortons has sold a significant number of muffins in recent years, yet customer feedback is mixed; some feel the quality has declined, noting that the texture and freshness fall short of expectations. Additionally, flavor consistency vary by location. Reddit user SmartTrender noted: “I am pretty sure they had this flavor muffin in the past and the taste was better. They probably changed something in the formula to save cost. And of course the price is more than the last time as well.”
Bigger Picture / Why It Matters
The items sold at fast-food chains have evolved from simple side dishes into meals that customers specifically seek out. Key factors influencing people’s choice include freshness, portion size, and taste, as well as price. The premium cost associated with some of these desserts creates higher expectations when consuming them and a truly great fast-food dessert has to be consistent in terms of price, freshness, and indulgence.
