Grabbing a coffee used to be simple: order your drink, maybe add a pastry, and be on your way. But these days, a quick coffee run can come with a surprising number of add-ons and suggestions designed to bump up your total.
From trendy protein boosts to “house-made” syrups and strategic questions at the register, coffee shop upselling has become a common strategy. Many of these upgrades may sound small, but they can quietly add several dollars to your order before you even realize it.
Baristas themselves say some of these tactics are part of the job, and they’re often trained to suggest extras that customers might not have planned on ordering. Here are some of the most common ways coffee shops try to get you to spend a little more.
Charging Extra for Alternative Milks
Estimated Upsell Cost: $.50–$1
Many coffee shops now charge extra for non-dairy milk options like oat, almond, or coconut milk, even though they’ve become incredibly common orders.
With dairy-free diets and plant-based trends growing, this small add-on has quietly become one of the most consistent ways cafes increase the cost of a simple latte.
The Classic ‘Anything Else Today?’ Prompt
Estimated Upsell Cost: $2.50–$6, depending on what gets added
One of the simplest upsell techniques is asking customers if they want anything else after they’ve already finished ordering.
According to one barista on Reddit, this tactic works surprisingly often because customers don’t always register it as a sales move: “Is there anything else I can get you today? More often than not the customer says ‘you know what I’ll do a muffin too!’ Sometimes a double up ‘is that all today?’ Finish typing in order then follow up with that first question! Customers don’t register it as anything but you doing your job and sometimes make them think!”
By the time customers hear the question, they’re already mentally picturing their order, and it’s easy to tack on one more treat.
Specialty House-Made Syrups
Estimated Upsell Cost: $0.75–$1.50
“House-made” syrups sound artisanal and exclusive, but they’re often just flavored sweeteners that can quickly inflate the price of a drink.
Coffee shops often promote seasonal or specialty syrups like lavender, brown sugar, or rosemary vanilla to make drinks seem more unique — and more expensive.
Protein Powder Add-Ins
Estimated Upsell Cost: $1.50–$3
With high-protein diets trending, some coffee shops now offer protein powder blended into cold brews, lattes, or smoothies.
Marketed as a healthier upgrade, protein add-ins can significantly increase the price of a drink that was originally just coffee and milk.
Extra Espresso Shots
Estimated Upsell Cost: $1–$2
Baristas frequently suggest adding an extra shot for “more flavor” or “a stronger drink.”
While the extra caffeine might sound appealing, it’s one of the easiest and most profitable upgrades cafés can suggest.
Trending on Cheapism
Fancy Foam and Cold Foam Toppings
Estimated Upsell Cost: $1–$1.75
Cold foam and flavored foam toppings have exploded in popularity thanks to social media coffee trends.
From sweet cream foam to flavored matcha or pumpkin foam, these toppings make drinks feel premium, even though they’re mostly just flavored milk. You’d be wise to skip ’em.
Suggested Pastry Pairings
Estimated Upsell Cost: $3–$6
Baristas often recommend a pastry that “pairs well” with a drink to encourage customers to add food to their order.
One barista on Reddit explained that the trick is to casually suggest something specific rather than asking a broad question. “After the customer orders their drink, ask them if they’d like to add something specific like a pastry or a breakfast taco to have with their coffee. The key is to be specific and nonchalant, like you don’t really care if they say yes or no and more like you’re doing them a favor/looking out for a homie who might be hungry but didn’t think about it.”
Tricky, tricky.
Larger Drink Sizes
Estimated Upsell Cost: $0.75–$1.50
Coffee shops often highlight medium or large sizes, making them seem like a better deal than the smallest option. (We see you, Starbucks.)
Many customers end up paying more for just a few extra ounces of coffee or milk, especially when menu boards emphasize bigger sizes or bundle them with extra shots or toppings.
Sign up for our newsletter
More From Cheapism
- 15 Things to Never Do When Ordering Coffee — Before your next caffeine run, brush up on the coffee shop behaviors that irritate baristas, slow down the line, and make everyone’s morning worse.
- I’m a Coffee Snob and I Finally Found a Cheap Coffee That I Love — Rising grocery prices pushed one picky coffee drinker to test budget grounds under $10 and find a few surprisingly solid cheap brews.
- 7 Best Fast-Food Iced Coffees, Ranked — One writer sampled seven popular fast-food iced coffees and ranked them by how well they balance sweetness, flavor, and actual coffee taste.
