Fast-food chains are currently vying for dominance in the fried chicken sandwich market, but this battle has been going on for years. Independent restaurants and local spots in certain regions had already introduced legendary sandwiches that were acclaimed by their customers, and some of these have gained so much renown that they have become destinations in their own right according to TripAdvisor and Yelp. Here are the non-fast-food restaurants serving up the best chicken sandwiches!
Howlin’ Ray’s – Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich
Howlin’ Ray’s is renowned for sparking the hot chicken craze in Southern California. Its Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich features a jumbo chicken breast with an exceptionally crispy, highly seasoned crust, layered with house-made slaw, pickles, and comeback sauce. This sandwich is a testament to the reputation it has earned nationwide. TripAdvisor user Max G commented: “Howlin’ Ray’s offers some of the best, and definitely spiciest, fried chicken I’ve ever eaten. No wonder the lines form every day.”
Boxcar Betty’s – Boxcar Sandwich
In Charleston, South Carolina, Boxcar Betty’s sells its Boxcar sandwich, which frequently ranks among the most acclaimed in the United States. The cooks focus on using fresh, locally sourced ingredients; the sandwich features buttermilk fried chicken, pimiento cheese, peach slaw, and house-made pickles. TripAdvisor user Ruth L noted: “It’s a thick, tasty chicken with interesting sauces like bacon jelly, and sides, including awesome hand-cut fries.”
Husk – Fried Chicken Sandwich
Husk chef Sean Brock decided to put a fresh spin on the Southern ingredients of his restaurant’s fried chicken sandwich through modern interpretations. Heritage ingredients, house-made pickles, a freshly baked bun, and regional sourcing transformed this sandwich, originally from Charleston and now a Nashville staple, into a signature lunch item, one of the best chicken sandwiches. TripAdvisor user Mike Palazzolo noted: “From the atmosphere to the food and great service, it was outstanding!”
The Eagle – Fried Chicken Sandwich
The Eagle restaurant in Cincinnati, Ohio, built its reputation on Amish-style fried chicken. Often recommended by Midwest food critics, the restaurant’s sandwich features brined chicken, spicy honey, thick-cut pickles, and house slaw. TripAdvisor user nic_leon2005 opined: “The fried chicken lives up to the hype and is a must-order. It’s perfectly juicy and moist with a nicely crisp breading and paired with a spicy honey sauce.”
Pine State Biscuits – Reggie Deluxe
One of Portland’s most iconic breakfast sandwiches is the Reggie Deluxe from Pine State Biscuits. A standout on must-eat lists for the Pacific Northwest, this dish features a combination of fried chicken, cheddar, bacon, gravy, and most notably, a biscuit instead of bread. TripAdvisor user TXMARTINS remarked about one of the best chicken sandwiches: “The Reggie is a boneless piece of chicken on a fluffy biscuit smothered in gravy, cheese, and egg that is understandably their most popular item.”
Trending on Cheapism
Mother’s Ruin – Hot Chicken Sandwich
One of Nashville’s modern hot chicken sandwiches is the one from Mother’s Ruin, featuring an extra-crispy coating, a bold spice blend, house-made pickles, and a potato bun; locals cite it as one of the most prized sandwiches. Ubereats user Dexter P noted: “It’s one of the best chicken sandwiches in Nashville.”
The Crack Shack – Señor Croque
The Señor Croque was created by chefs Richard Blais and Jon Sloan, featuring a fried chicken thigh, crispy cheese, a runny egg, and miso-maple butter, that makes it one of the best chicken sandwiches. Their goal was to elevate the fast-casual approach to fried chicken in San Diego, California. TripAdvisor user Mike R described: “The chicken was really crispy and slightly seasoned. I’d have preferred a little more herbs or seasoning to boost the chicken flavor.”
Bird Bird Biscuit – Queen Beak
Another one of the best chicken sandwiches that ranks high among breakfast options in Austin, Texas, is the Queen Beak, from Bird Bird Biscuits. This neighborhood spot captured the nation’s attention with its sandwich featuring a fried chicken breast, honey butter, bacon, and a biscuit. TripAdvisor user ellenoftroy728 revealed: “The chicken was so juicy and crisp, flavor was outstanding.”
Sign up for our newsletter
Federal Donuts & Chicken – Fried Chicken Sandwich
Federal Donuts & Chicken has contributed to the chicken sandwich craze in Philadelphia since opening its doors, thanks to founders Michael Solomonov and Steve Cook. What makes this one of the best chicken sandwiches is the freshly fried and features pepper relish, a potato roll, and distinctive spice blends. TripAdvisor user go4theglobe mentioned: “One of the best fried chicken sandwiches I’ve ever had, and it’s cheap too!”
Root & Bone – Fried Chicken Biscuit Sandwich
In addition to its New York City location, Root & Bone has opened other venues to showcase its Southern comfort food, featuring elevated versions of the dishes. Its fried chicken biscuit sandwich is one of the best chicken sandwiches, and it’s made with buttermilk fried chicken, a biscuit, pepper jelly, and house-made pickles. Yelp user Kathy X noted: “The fried chicken had an incredible crispiness, was tender, and bursting with flavor. I couldn’t really discern the sweet tea taste, but I didn’t mind.”
HiHo Cheeseburger – Fried Chicken Sandwich
HiHo Cheeseburger is best known for its burgers, but they have one of the best chicken sandwiches that shouldn’t be overlooked. Many food critics highly recommend it as one of the top spots in Southern California. This sandwich features thick buttermilk-brined chicken, house slaw, dill pickles, and a soft brioche bun. Yelp user Jason B commented: “You can’t miss it, it’s the best made-to-order chicken tender, with fixing piled high on a soft, fresh bun.”
Coqodaq – Golden Nugget Sandwich
One of the high-profile destinations serving one of the best chicken sandwiches is Coqodaq, in New York City. Their dish, the Golden Nugget Sandwich, draws inspiration from Korea, featuring premium ingredients and a dreamlike presentation by the chef. It’s a truly luxurious take on the fried chicken sandwich. Yelp user Cindy Z remarked: “The fun part was being able to dip it into the various sauces they offered.”
Conclusion
When you’re craving a fried chicken sandwich, you don’t have to limit yourself to fast-food chains or drive-thru. These independent restaurants aim to elevate food quality by using regional ingredients and achieving some of the best chicken sandwiches. Chefs’ techniques and the combination of distinct flavors add a layer of complexity.
