New York City is home to many famous restaurants, spots that have earned their reputation through movie appearances, social media buzz, and outstanding food that keeps customers coming back. These are the places locals take visiting friends and family, yet might prefer to keep to themselves to avoid price hikes and overcrowding according to Reddit users and Google Reviews. We’re letting you in on the secret of hidden NYC restaurants!
L’Industrie Pizzeria – Williamsburg, Brooklyn
Manhattan pizzerias tend to get packed with both locals and tourists. However, savvy locals know they can count on L’Industrie Pizzeria, which prepares its dough using high-quality imported ingredients and serves up a crust that is both crisp and chewy, along with its famous burrata slice. In recent years, it has lost its label of one of the “hidden NYC restaurants” status as it has garnered national attention. Reddit user jpnh33 commented: “Is by far and away the best pizza by the slice I have ever had. It meets the hype and has raised the bar a bit too high for my liking.”
Los Tacos No. 1 – Chelsea Market
Tacos No. 1 is located in Chelsea Market, one of New York’s busiest areas, yet these fresh tortillas often go overlooked and turn the place into one of the hidden NYC restaurants. They are prepared daily, with the ‘adobada’, ‘carne asada’, and ‘nopales’ variety being the most prized by diners, who consider it one of the best places in the city to eat tacos. Reddit user Possible-Source-2454 revealed: “They do literally everything from scratch. They make their own dough, make tortillas to order, grill their veggies for salsa.”
Xi’an Famous Foods – Queens
Xi’an’s original location is in Flushing, Queens, and has since expanded across New York City. The cooks prepare the dishes from scratch, you can see them kneading noodles in the kitchen, and their hand-pulled noodles, spicy cumin lamb, and ‘liang pi’ cold noodles are among New Yorkers’ favorites. They don’t hide any process in the kitchen in one of this hidden NYC restaurants. Reddit user suryassays noted: “The noodles and spice level at the Chinatown spot are as good as ever for me!”
Spicy Village – Chinatown
Passersby might not be drawn to Spicy Village, as it looks like a very modest restaurant from the outside, it’s perfect for one of these hidden NYC restaurants. However, inside, its Henan-style noodles have earned it a legendary reputation among locals. Dishes featuring chicken, potatoes, peppers, and handmade noodles, perfect for sharing, have made it a true hidden gem. Google Reviews user George Moss noted: “This is one of the best spots in Chinatown that is worth the hype. I can only speak to the Big Tray Chicken that is a unique dish not to be found elsewhere.”
Court Street Grocers – Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn
The sandwiches at Court Street Grocers are among the most highly regarded by locals. Fresh bread, premium meats, and inventive combinations featuring house-made sauces have established this place as one of the best in the area, and also stands out among hidden NYC restaurants. Regular customers say they have never tried a sandwich there that they didn’t like. Google Reviews user Michael Cheng opined: “I had the pork roll which is a bacon, egg and cheese, and the bacon was essentially crispy. The vibes are nice in there and sandwiches are good.”
Trending on Cheapism
Katz’s Delicatessen… At 10 PM -New York City
We know Katz isn’t one of the hidden NYC restaurants, millions of people know about it, but the best time to visit is indeed a secret. Locals head to Katz late at night for its pastrami sandwiches; it really comes down to knowing exactly when to visit this legendary deli. Google Reviews user Ramazan Likoglu noted: “When you go inside, it looks like a living museum, and they give each customer a ticket that you have to give it later to the cashier. The meat there is prepared by salting for up to 30 days.”
Bolivian Llama Party – Sunnyside, Queens
The borough of Queens is one of New York’s most diverse areas when it comes to food, and a prime example is Bolivian Llama Party in Sunnyside. This restaurant prepares Bolivian specialties, such as sandwiches and ‘salteñas’, garnering rave reviews while remaining largely unknown to tourists. This is a gem among the hidden NYC restaurants. Google Reviews user RJ commented: “The ‘salteña’ was worth the wait! Super savory and filling, the green sauce is the perfect accompaniment. I think they made it fresh because there was a 15-minutes wait.”
Raku – East Village
Raku’s handmade udon in the East Village is among the city’s top choices. The flavor of the broth shines through in every dish, the noodles are fresh, and reviews from Japanese diners are consistently positive, so the place certainly doesn’t lack recognition but still maintains its “hidden NYC restaurants” label. Google Reviews user Firestrike noted: “The noodles were chewy and thick, and the broth had a delicious savory flavor with notes of seaweed. I like those a lot.”
Sign up for our newsletter
Ba Xuyen – Sunset Park, Brooklyn
Ba Xuyen bakery sells banh mi, a Vietnamese sandwich made with a baguette of white flour and rice flour. Inside, it features pickled carrots, daikon, and onions, along with cilantro and meat or tofu. They bake their own bread daily, resulting in sandwiches with a crispy crust and airy interior, qualities their customers appreciate. Remarkably, prices remain affordable despite the exceptional quality of the food. Google Reviews user Lunch Lady observed: “Ba Xuyen has my favorite bread, crispy without destroying your mouth and soft inside, and they go heavy on the cilantro.”
Casa Adela – Alphabet City, New York
Casa Adela specializes in authentic Puerto Rican cuisine. Dishes such as roast pork, rice and beans, mofongo, and daily specials receive glowing reviews from customers for their homemade quality in Alphabet City, distinct from typical restaurant-style fare. It is one of the East Village’s great institutions, the kind locals try to keep a secret. Google Reviews user ReedH revealed about one of these hidden NYC restaurants: “It’s a small restaurant and there was a wait for a table. My shrimp mofongo was excellent, authentic, packed with flavor and well worth ordering.”
Lucali – Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn
Lucali has been garnering national acclaim for some time now, yet it still feels like a neighborhood pizzeria rather than a tourist attraction. This spot in Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn serves homemade pizzas and calzones, but the restaurant’s atmosphere is just as appealing as the food itself; some fans even rank it among the best in the United States. Google Reviews user Anushka Mankunath commented: “We shared one pizza, one calzone, and one pasta and felt it was the perfect amount of food to share. We had half cheese and half pepperoni for the pizza, and for the calzone added spicy peppers, mushrooms and shallots.”
Ayada Thai – Elmhurst, Queens
Ayada Thai, the restaurant serving international cuisine, is located in the Elmhurst neighborhood. It offers Thai curries, crispy pork, and regional specialties that are well-loved by its regulars. While Manhattan certainly has its share of bustling Thai spots, locals say that Ayada Thai is right up there when it comes to food quality. Google Reviews user Pancho remarked: “Every dish we ordered was packed with bold, authentic flavors and executed perfectly.”
Joe’s Steam Rice Roll – Flushing, Queens
The small shop in Flushing, Queens, that specializes almost exclusively in Cantonese cuisine is called Joe’s Steam Rice Roll. Customers come here to try Cantonese rice noodle rolls that are prepared fresh and ready to eat. The preparation process, featuring delicate sheets of rice noodle wrapped around shrimp, beef, or pork and steamed right before serving, captivates customers, who watch the process with fascination. Reddit user mikebassman remarked: “This is fabulous and cheap. I’ve only tried the location in Flushing. For my money, it’s the best rice rolls out there.”
Taste Good Malaysian Cuisine – Elmhurst, Queens
Classic Malaysian dishes can also be enjoyed at Taste Good Malaysian Cuisine, a spot that captivates both visitors and locals. Positive reviews highlight the restaurant’s authenticity, making it one of the most rewarding hidden food gems in Queens. This is one of the hidden NYC restaurants which perfectly represents international cuisine. Google Reviews user Real_Lexus opined: “My friend and I have ordered Shrimp Wonton Soup, six skewers of pork Malaysian Satay Panggang, Sambal shrimp and it was delicious, but you need to order white rice, because it doesn’t come with it.”
Frankel’s Delicatessen – Greenpoint, Brooklyn
Ancient Jewish traditions and modern craftsmanship come together in Brooklyn’s Greenpoint neighborhood to create Frankel’s Delicatessen, another one of the hidden NYC restaurants. Standout dishes include hand-sliced smoked salmon, outstanding breakfast sandwiches, homemade bagels, and matzo ball soup. For locals, Frankel’s is one of the most reliable breakfast spots in Brooklyn. Reddit user LeftReflection6620 observed: “Pastrami egg and cheese is usually the go to here but had to switch it up to not feel like a fatty.”
Why New Yorkers Usually Eat Outside The Tourist Districts
The incredible variety and quality of these hidden NYC restaurants it’s one of their greatest strengths, something you can find in almost any neighborhood, and not just at the famous restaurants, as we’ve shown you with lesser-known spots. You can venture beyond Midtown and Times Square to enjoy a great sandwich, a bowl of noodles, or a slice of pizza. Explore Flushing, Elmhurst, Carroll Gardens, Sunset Park, and the Lower East Side to discover these places serving up unique recipes.
