When Costco discontinued its combo pizza, fans were so devastated that they launched a Change.org petition alongside an impassioned Costco pizza manifesto. The combo pizza, they wrote, “ignites a party of tremendous flavor in the mouths of millions of Costco membership holders.”
This is all to say that Costco superfans are also pizza heads. Some of those fans shared what they think Costco’s best frozen pizzas are.
Note: Prices and availability may vary by location and are subject to change.
1. Motor City Pizza Co.
$18 (2 ct. of ultimate meat) from Instacart
Motor City Pizza Co. was a clear standout among Redditors, who voted the Detroit-style deep dish brand to the top of the thread. If you like thick-crust pizza (and meat), you’re sure to enjoy these Michigan-made pies with their distinct square shape, airy dough, and high-edged crust.
2. Kirkland Signature Pepperoni Pizza
$16 (4 ct.) from Business Delivery
Costco’s in-house Kirkland brand takes second place with its frozen pepperoni pizza. “My husband is a high school teacher and he buys these for after school events,” a Redditor writes, adding that these thin crust pies are “good value.” Of course, they’re tasty, too. Just crank your oven to 425 Fahrenheit, wait 12 to 15 minutes, and you’ve got a pie that’ll please any pepperoni lover.
3. Frozen Costco Food Court Pizza
$10 from Costco’s food court
While Costco members are no doubt familiar with the retailer’s affordable, extra-cheesy, and filling food court pizza, you may not have realized that it freezes well, too. One superfan suggests thawing the food court pies in the oven for 10 minutes, adding that “it taste just like it was made fresh.” (Our own research suggests that cooking the pizza on a stovetop, while unorthodox, is the best method for reheating a cheesy, crispy slice).
4. Kirkland Signature Cheese Pizza
$13 (4 ct.) from Costco Business Delivery
Buy toppings separately and create your own double pepperoni pizza on a budget, one Redditor writes. Or, if you’re vegetarian, enjoy this meat-free Kirkland Signature frozen pizza on its own. Either way, this Kirkland frozen pizza earns high marks despite its simplicity.
5. Sabatasso’s Pizza Singles
$15 (12 ct.) from Instacart
On a diet? Prefer bite-sized pies? Consider Sabatasso’s pizza singles, which one superfan described as one of his “favorite” frozen pizzas. Prepare them in the microwave or oven and follow the cooking instructions on the package.
For more great shopping tips and Costco content, please sign up for our free newsletters.
