Cheapism is editorially independent. We may earn a commission if you buy through links on our site.

Two people clinking glasses of red wine over a dinner table with a salad, candles, and a romantic atmosphere.
Inside Creative House/istockphoto

Love is in the air, along with the sound of millions of people trying to make restaurant reservations. 

Valentine’s Day dining out is the second busiest time of the year for restaurants, and it presents some very unique and decidedly unromantic problems for couples. While wining and dining your sweetheart may be what they want, consider doing it any other day of the year. Here’s why you should skip the restaurant res and cook up some love at home instead.

You Can’t Order What You Want

Fine dining restaurant, young woman reading a paper menu
LeoPatrizi/istockphoto

Want to take your love out for their favorite meal? You better check whether the restaurant will actually have that dish available. Most places have a set menu on Valentine’s Day, with only a few options available in order to streamline things in the kitchen. They’re usually pretty stereotypical “romantic” foods, too, like steak, lobster, and lots of chocolate. They’re designed for logistics, so they’re usually not great. 

It’s More Expensive

Close up of woman hand with a Bill With American Dollars which people, payment and finances concept
Sasithorn Phuapankasemsuk/istockphoto

Supply and demand applies in restaurants just like everywhere else. You want a Valentine’s Day reservation? You’re going to pay more for it than on any other day — sometimes way more. Considering the abbreviated menus and all the other hassle, it’s just not worth the super high price.

Restaurant Employees Hate It

Hectic cooks working in a busy commercial kitchen at a restaurant - food and drink establishment concepts
Hispanolistic/istockphoto

Service industry employees hate Valentine’s Day, and some even call it “rookie night” because so many people go out to eat that don’t normally. Restaurants sometimes do three times more business than usual, so it’s stressful and fast-paced. Plus, many customers expect everything to be perfect, and when it’s not, they get irate. Do yourself and restaurant employees a favor and just skip it — or at least treat your server with kindness and tip generously if you do go out.

It’s Too Crowded

London, UK - August 31, 2019: View through the window of staff and customers inside Buns and Buns restaurant in Covent Garden Market, one of the most popular tourist sites in London, UK.
Alena Kravchenko/istockphoto

Is sitting shoulder-to-shoulder in a restaurant along with 18 other couples romantic to you? It’ll be hard to focus only on each other when there’s so much going on around you in a busy dining room. Plus, you may only be able to score a very early or very late reservation, throwing other plans that night out the window.

You’ll Be Rushed

Couple, Romantic, Dinner, Togetherness, Holiday
Inside Creative House/istockphoto

Turning over three times as many tables as a regular night means that you’ll be rushed through your meal, especially if you normally enjoy a leisurely-paced dinner. There’s going to be two or three other couples that still need to use your table before the restaurant closes, so you won’t be able to chat over an extra glass of wine.

You Have To Plan Way Ahead of Time

New York, USA 11/25/2017: Long lines form in front of highly popular Juliana's Pizza which is a long standing favorite for pizza lovers visiting Brooklyn.
Grandbrothers/istockphoto

Have you made your Valentine’s Day reservation yet? No? Fat chance now. If you haven’t made it a couple weeks before the big day, chances are your top restaurant picks are already booked solid. Most restaurants don’t reserve tables for walk-ins for the holiday, either, so just showing up and waiting is a hopeless endeavor. 

It’ll Be Really Loud

Group of people standing by bar counter, dinking cocktails
zoranm/istockphoto

WHAT? I CAN’T HEAR YOU! THE MUSIC IS TOO LOUD AND THERE’S SO MANY PEOPLE TALKING AT ONCE. I CAN BARELY HEAR THE SERVER, SO LET’S JUST GO HOME AND WATCH A MOVIE. OK? GREAT.

Parking Hassles and Transportation Headaches

Parking garage with cars
antpkr/istockphoto

With so many restaurants packed on Valentine’s Day, nearby streets and parking lots are likely to be full, valet services charge extra, and surge pricing on rideshare apps can make getting there or home more expensive and stressful. Doesn’t your dining room at home sound so much better now?

More From Cheapism

A thick steak labeled "medium" sits on a red plate with yellow sauce; next to it is a bowl of sliced steak, grilled vegetables, and crispy toppings—dishes that might be found at steakhouses not worth visiting.
Ivy C./Yelp / Wilder Shaw/Cheapism

Meet the Writer

Lacey Muszynski is a staff writer at Cheapism covering food, travel, and more. She has over 15 years of writing and editing experience, and her restaurant reviews and recipes have previously appeared in Serious Eats, Thrillist, and countless publications in her home state of Wisconsin.