Cheapism is editorially independent. We may earn a commission if you buy through links on our site.

Cropped shot of a young woman enjoying a head massage at a spa
PeopleImages/istockphoto

If you spend time on Reddit’s r/frugal forum, you might start to feel guilty for all the little treats you enjoy throughout the week. I mean, these are real penny-pinchers — the kind who’ll reuse a Ziploc bag, cut their own hair, and water down their milk to save a few bucks. But a recent thread reveals that even the biggest cheapskates have a few indulgent habits and expenses. Here are nine of frugal Redditors’ most extravagant expenses.

Personal Trainer

Sportsman in plank position exercising dumbbell push-ups
martin-dm/istockphoto

You’d think that thrifty Redditors would pump iron at the cheapest local gym — no matter how grimy. But one commenter says that they pay “an extortionate amount” for a premium personal trainer, spending more than four times the going rate. Even so, they say it’s worth it; they’ve been pain-free for the past seven years.

Massages

She knows exactly where all my tension lives
Charday Penn/istockphoto

Multiple Redditors say that they splurge on massages, with one commenter writing that they’re “so worth it” for the “many health and wellness benefits.” And if a massage is out of your price range, someone suggests you treat yourself to a “poor man’s massage,” aka a session with a foam roller.

Fancy Cheeses

AlexKozlov/istockphoto

If there’s one thing we could all learn from the French, it’s the ability to pause and enjoy life’s simple pleasures, including a round of top-shelf Camembert. Even the stingiest Redditors know this. One commenter writes that good cheese (and coffee) make a “world of difference.” “If you have a Trader Joe’s near you, their fancy cheese is fantastic and usually very comparable in quality but less costly than Whole Foods,” a Redditor adds.

Related: 20 Everyday Items That Are Worth Splurging On

Premium Teas

Warm green tea on a wooden table.
kuppa_rock/istockphoto

Speaking of life’s simple pleasures, have you ever enjoyed a cup of premium green tea? One Redditor swears it’s worth spending $30 to $40 more than grocery store tea, writing that a premium brew is “noticeably more delicious in so many ways.” They recommend shopping online for Ikkyu tea, though “any loose leaf sencha you find sourced from Japan is miles beyond” what you’ll find at the store.

Related: 7 Everyday Items You Should Never Skimp On, According to Redditors

Shoes

AzmanL/istockphoto

For some on r/Frugal, comfortable premium shoes are a necessity because of health issues like rheumatoid arthritis and plantar fasciitis. One commenter writes that “supportive shoes are invaluable,” especially when you’re suffering from joint pain.

Related: Want To Start Living Frugally? Redditors Share Their Best Advice

Travel

Backpacker crossing road on urban street, sight seeing, exploration, cool
JohnnyGreig/istockphoto

Travel came up throughout the thread, with some sharing that vacationing is the reason they’re frugal in the first place. So save up those credit card miles and tighten your belts now. The payoff, Redditors say, is worth it.

Related: Why Is Spirit Airlines So Cheap — and Is It Safe?

Pets

Bearded man comfortably sitting on a coach reading a book and holding his dog .
MaFelipe/istockphoto

It’s heartening to see that thrifty Redditors aren’t cheapskates when it comes to their pets’ well-being and health. “I will spare no expense to keep (my dog) healthy and happy,” one comment reads.

For more budget-focused coverage and advice, please sign up for our free newsletters.

Paper Towels

Young woman wearing protective face mask with shopping basket, holding pack of toilet paper and looking at it, COVID-19 pandemic era
zoranm/istockphoto

One tight-fisted Redditor swears that their one splurge is to buy premium Viva-brand paper towels — and even then, they say that they use them “very sparingly.” If fancy paper towels truly are your biggest indulgence — and you’re not completely strapped for cash — we have a suggestion for you: Treat yourself once in a while!

Fresh Fruit

Stieglitz/istockphoto

It’s indicative of how expensive groceries have become that Redditors consider fresh fruit a spendy item. “Whenever I fantasize about what I’d do if I won the lottery, one of the first things I think about is eating as many raspberries as I want,” a Redditor shares.

Meet the Writer

Maxwell is a California-based writer who got his start in print journalism, a career that satisfies his love of research. That penchant for learning also fuels his desire to be a discerning consumer — whether he’s looking for his next pair of headphones or rock-climbing shoes. When he’s not hunched over his laptop, you can find Maxwell sending routes at the crag, playing Magic: The Gathering, or hanging out with his buddies at the bar. As a UCSC alumnus, he’s also a proud banana slug. You can reach him at [email protected].