Ever-popular sub shop Jimmy John’s has decided to switch up its rewards system, and not a minute too soon for most fans of the chain. The key difference this time? Jimmy John’s rewards that people might actually want.
Improved, Hopefully
Jimmy John’s old “rewards” system was far from popular. Thread after thread after thread exists on Reddit full of complaints, closely matched by plenty of social media discourse. Previously dubbed “Freaky Fast Rewards,” the internet is full of people scratching their collective heads over it, calling it things like “really stupid” and “a joke.”
The Random, Surprise Awards Are Gone
The reason that Jimmy John’s old rewards system stunk up so much air was probably because of the randomized format, where participants would receive surprise rewards based on purchase history, bonus offers, and in-app activity. “I’ve been eating Jimmy John’s for probably 10 years now, said one fan, “and I think the only thing I’ve ever gotten free was a soda pop or a cookie”. The promise of a free cookie after 10 years of loyalty is anything but compelling.
How the New Jimmy John’s Rewards Program Works
Ole’ James John has finally cooked up a far better, more straightforward system. Now known as JJ Rewards, you’ll earn 10 points for every dollar you spend. You can redeem them any time on the app or website, and you’ll be able to cash them in for sandwiches this time. Cookies and drinks are also options, if you prefer those instead. You’ll also receive a free sandwich after signing up and placing your first order of $5 or more, which is valid for any regular-sized Favorite, Original, or Plain Slim sandwich. You’ll also receive a birthday surprise, though the company doesn’t specify what that includes. In the past, participants have received a free sandwich, but its not yet clear if that remains the case.
Is the New Jimmy John’s Rewards Program Better?
So far, the new rewards have had a much warmer reception than the previous. Some are calling it a positive change, while others are worried it will cause you to spend more in the long run.
Meaningless Achievements Are Still in Play
Don’t worry, though. Jimmy John’s also offers achievement badges, if you are somebody who prefers rewards that aren’t real.
Trending on Cheapism
When Does Jimmy John’s Start the J.J. Rewards Program?
The new Jimmy John’s rewards program, JJ Rewards, launched on September 29, 2025, and is now live. Start hoardin’ those points.
More Fast-Food Deals and News
- How To Get Free Fast Food at 27 Chain Restaurants — If you lack the patience to accumulate points on a loyalty or rewards program over multiple visits, consider these ways to score free fast food deals right now.
- Fast-Food Hack: How to Score 50-Cent Bread Loaves at This Popular Sandwich Shop — Of all the fast-food hacks we’ve heard about, there is one that flies under the radar that continuously gets slept on.
- The 10 Best Sandwich Chains, Ranked — We live in a world of fast-food chain sandwiches, and depending on the town you live in, the best sandwich near you might actually be the chain down the street.
