There are plenty of cosmetics, toiletries, and other personal-care products out there that claim to help us look and feel our best. But which ones are worth the money, and which ones are better off staying on the store shelves? From sunscreen to hair dryers, we’ve rounded up a dozen tried-and-true favorites that have earned the praise of buyers and experts, and a dozen others that should make you think twice.
BUY: ESTEE LAUDER DOUBLE WEAR STAY-IN-PLACE MAKEUP
Price: $42 | Buy it at Ulta Tired of foundation that seems to just slide off your face as the day wears on? Ulta reviewers say this matte-finish Estee Lauder formula lives up to its long-lived billing, and over 40 shades mean you can find the exact match for your skin.
SKIP: POWDER FOUNDATIONS
BUY: L’OREAL PARIS VOLUMINOUS SUPERSTAR MASCARA
Price: $9.76 | Buy it at Walmart Celebrity makeup artists unanimously recommend this drugstore cheapie, which they say is a winner because it lengthens and thickens equally well. It’s available in both washable and waterproof versions.
SKIP: HIGH-END MASCARA
BUY: DHC DEEP CLEANSING OIL
Price: $28 | Buy it at DermStore This all-purpose cleanser easily “melts off” makeup and doesn’t leave a residue, according to happy DermStore reviewers. The formula includes olive oil and vitamin E to keep skin moist.
Trending on Cheapism
SKIP: MAKEUP REMOVER WIPES
BUY: BENEFIT BENETINT CHEEK & LIP STAIN
Price: $30 | Buy it at Sephora This longtime favorite gets a shout-out from Vogue for creating that hard-to-replicate natural flush that comes when blood rushes to our cheeks — and hundreds of fans at Sephora agree. The sheer color is kiss- and smudge-resistant.
SKIP: BLUSH THAT’S TOO BOLD
Sign up for our newsletter
BUY: EQUATE SPORT LOTION SPF 50
Price: $4.98 | Buy it at Walmart Could it be? This humble, inexpensive Walmart store brand takes a top placement in Consumer Reports testing, notching high marks for its UVA and UVB protection and beating many pricier brands. It’s water-resistant for up to 80 minutes and is one of Cheapism’s top picks for best sunscreen.
SKIP: ULTRA-HIGH SPF SUNSCREENS
BUY: ART NATURALS ARGAN OIL SHAMPOO AND CONDITIONER
Price: $26.13 | Buy it at Amazon This set is a No. 1 best seller among Amazon’s dizzying array of shampoos and conditioners. Reviewers rave that the salon-quality formula leaves hair strong and shiny. There are no potentially damaging parabens or sulfates, either.
SKIP: SHAMPOOS THAT CAN ENCOURAGE HAIR LOSS
BUY: AVEENO DAILY MOISTURIZING LOTION
Price: $6.12 | Buy it at Amazon A panel of testers at The Wirecutter gives Aveeno the thumbs-up over several competing brands. Why? It’s easy to rub in, smells inoffensive and is less greasy — and less pricey — than other lotions.
SKIP: HEAVILY SCENTED BODY LOTION
BUY: DIFFERIN GEL ACNE TREATMENT
Price: $11.99 | Buy it at Amazon If you’re still struggling with occasional breakouts, this retinoid gel — the first approved for over-the-counter use — can make quick work of them. An Allure “Best of Beauty” award winner, it treats both clogged pores and inflammation.
SKIP: ACNE PRODUCTS WITH LOTS OF BENZOYL PEROXIDE
BUY: R.E.M. SPRING FACIAL HAIR REMOVER
Price: $17.95 | Buy it at Amazon Tired of tweezing those pesky facial hairs? Devotees highly recommend this easy-to-bend stainless-steel spring, perfect for more quickly grabbing unwanted hairs — root and all — from the lips, chin and other sensitive areas.
SKIP: RAZORS (FOR FEMALE FACIAL HAIR)
BUY: ORAL-B GLIDE FLOSS PICKS
Price: $21.02 | Buy it at Amazon Plastic picks and shred-resistant floss are a good combination, especially for reluctant flossers. Amazon reviewers say these picks make a tedious chore a lot less awkward, and many say they are less prone to breakage and do better between crowded teeth than other varieties.
SKIP: WATER FLOSSERS
BUY: ORAL-B PRO 1000 POWER TOOTHBRUSH
Price: $45 | Buy it at Walmart Upgrading from a manual makes sense — researchers have given electrics a slight edge for combatting plaque and gingivitis — but a basic one will do just fine. Reviewers give a nod to the basic Oral-B Pro 1000, which has a pressure sensor and a timer that helps you brush each area equally. It’s also one of Cheapism’s favorite electric toothbrushes.
SKIP: SMART TOOTHBRUSHES
BUY: REVLON PRO COLLECTION SALON INFRARED STYLER
Price: $16.69 | Buy it at Walmart Sure, you could spend $400 on this well-reviewed Dyson, but … ouch. Buyers praise this inexpensive Revlon for fast and gentle drying at a low price; it’s also one of Cheapism’s favorite budget hair dryers.
SKIP: ULTRA HIGH-HEAT HAIR DRYERS