Cheapism is editorially independent. We may earn a commission if you buy through links on our site.

Clothes rack, old-fashioned suitcases, garden tools and interior goods selling at garage market in backyard
shironosov/istockphoto

Garage sale shopping either gives you chills of excitement or completely repulses you. There’s no doubt that used or unwanted items can offer some great deals if you’re willing to dig. But no matter how much you love the thrill of the score, there are some things you should never, ever get at a garage sale — no matter how cheap you are.

Underwear and Socks

Funny close-up picture of some messy kid socks
Lorerock81/istockphoto

This really doesn’t need an explanation. Buying old underwear is just kinda ick.

Old Video Games and Consoles

Taipei, Taiwan - February 20, 2018: A studio shot of a large heap of old video game cartridges.
robtek/istockphoto

While it may seem like a score to get a slightly used Xbox, until you get it home and plug it in you’ll have no idea if it works 

Shoes

Pyramid of shoes, Lyon, France
frederic prochasson/istockphoto

We’re not saying you should never buy shoes at a garage sale — sometimes there are some pretty cool vintage finds. But if you’re looking for everyday shoes or sneakers, it’s a bad idea to buy a secondhand pair. Shoes usually form to a wearer’s feet and are unlikely to offer you the right fit when already worn in. 

Electrical Items

Throw away old kitchen appliances. Disposal of electrical appliances in the card box. Find it in the trash. Throw the bread toaster in the trash.
Dennis Sihaloho/istockphoto

That toaster they don’t make anymore? Stay away. A cool vintage crockpot? Yeah, no.

Basically, anything that you plug in that’s already used runs the risk of sparking or malfunctioning. We don’t care what price items like this offer in savings. It’s simply not worth the potential danger. 

Swimsuits

Teenager, Smiling, Choosing, Bikini, Store
MesquitaFMS/istockphoto

Seriously? Why would you consider this? We don’t care how clean it looks or that you can wash it thoroughly. It still feels yucky to us. 

Baby Cribs and Bedding

Empty baby crib with stuffed toys inside
freemixer/istockphoto

Again, the safety thing. You have no idea how safe that used crib is, if a part of it broke, or even if it’s been recalled. Same with bedding, it could be worn out in a way that creates a danger. Just don’t mess with this stuff.

Mattresses

A black African-American man delivering a new mattress
Robin Gentry /istockphoto

Ew. If you’re that cheap, just buy the cheapest new mattress you can find, or use an air mattress. For the love of god. Bed bugs are very hard to see, so even if it looks fresh and clean, who really knows?

Car Seats

Child safety seat in the back of the car. Baby car seat for safety. Car interior. Car detailing
bigtunaonline/istockphoto

That car seat may have been involved in an accident. It may be expired, meaning the materials have worn down. This is an expense that is always worth paying for new.

Helmets

Bicycle safety helmets hang on metal wall in a bike shop.
Ratchat/istockphoto

Same thing as car seats: Maybe it’s been in a crash, maybe it’s deteriorated in a way you can’t even see. It’s worth paying extra money on something that keeps your head from cracking open.

Nonstick Cookware

Old scratched non-stick saucepan on the table.
Maliflower73/istockphoto

Even if you can’t see it, the teflon material may be worn down, meaning when you actually use it, you risk the pan flaking into your food. You can regularly find nonstick cookware on sale, which is a better bet.

Music

Customer browsing vybyl discs at a vintage flea market.
Maica/istockphoto

Whether it’s on a CD, vinyl, 8-track, or some other format, you won’t be able to find out if it skips or even plays until you try it on your home stereo. Don’t take the risk. 

Hats

Various traditional hats at a flea market in Vienna.
Leonsbox/istockphoto

One word: lice. Okay, more than one word. These things can have more than bugs, such as sweat and dirt. If you don’t mind that, you really should.

For more frugal shopping tips, please sign up for our free newsletters.

Meet the Writer

Jennifer Magid has worked as a writer and editor in publishing and marketing for almost two decades. She has written for outlets ranging from InStyle magazine to Psychology Today and for a number of grocery and personal care brands. Jennifer is frugal by proxy: She is married to a certified cheapskate, which has been good for her wallet but bad for her shoe and handbag collections. These days, she never, ever buys her fashions at full price. Jennifer holds a Master’s in Journalism from New York University. She lives in Connecticut with her family and an admittedly expensive-to-maintain standard poodle — the one anomaly in her cheap lifestyle. Find out more about Jennifer at www.jennifermagid.com. You can reach her at [email protected].