Cheapism is editorially independent. We may earn a commission if you buy through links on our site.

Grocery Store Purchases That Are a Total Waste of Money
Cheapism

Grocery shopping has turned into an art form. Inflation has attacked grocery stores in unthinkable ways and shoppers now have to approach the errand like it’s a battle zone, curating a well-thought-out plan based on sales and coupons to get out alive. There are some money-saving tips to keep in mind, and there are also purchases that should be avoided or made elsewhere, like the ones we’ve listed below. 

1. Pre-Cut Fruits & Vegetables

Fruit bowls in supermarket
gerenme/istockphoto

When it comes to purchasing produce, buy them whole, not pre-cut. You’ll pay more for prepared versions, likely because they require additional labor to cut and package.

2. Bottled Water

Large Number of Packed Bottled Drinking Water with Blue Caps
Ake Dynamic/istockphoto

Single-use plastic bottles of water cost more to purchase consistently than you’d spend on a filter for your sink or refrigerator to get your purified water that way. 

3. Pre-Made Salads

Costco Caesar Salad
Lacey Muszynski / Cheapism

Packaged salads, whether in plastic bowls or salad kits, are usually pricy compared to the DIY variety. You’d be better off buying lettuce and other in-season or on-sale produce to round out your own salad.

4. Microwavable Pancakes

4. Microwavable Pancakes
Cheapism

Pancakes are easy enough to throw together, and you can even make a big batch and freeze them. With that in mind, microwavable pancakes are better left behind the glass doors of the grocery store’s frozen food section.

5. Baby Carrots

Simple Truth Organic® Baby Carrots
Kroger

Baby carrots get put in your cart to get put in your fridge to their inevitable slime-coated death. They don’t maintain their integrity for very long and they also seem to be inconsistent with quality. Despite being generally affordable, whole carrots are even cheaper, they’re more versatile, and they last longer. Opt for those instead.

6. Single-Serve Yogurt Cups

6. Single-Serve Yogurt Cups
Amazon

You might pay $1 a piece for single-serve yogurts, or you can get a 32-ounce container for around $3 and portion it out yourself. There is a clearly better choice to be made here, and it looks something like not wasting your money on little cups of yogurt.

7. Out of Season Produce

Woman shopping for raw corn in supermarkets
TAO EDGE/istockphoto

Have you ever had a hankering for corn on the cob in December or craved a persimmon in June? Those are expensive cravings to satisfy. You might pay triple for corn on the cob when it’s out-of-season than you would when it’s in season. Force your tastebuds to want the appropriate seasonal produce.

8. Baking Mixes

various pancake mixes
Wilder Shaw / Cheapism

From pancake mix to cake mix, those little Betty Crocker boxes are often just comprised of ingredients you probably already have in the pantry (and that flour and sugar will stretch further than just one batch of cupcakes). Leave the mix alone and look up a recipe instead.

9. Bakery Items

9. Bakery Items
Wilder Shaw / Cheapism

Speaking of baking, if you grab baked goods from your grocery store, chances are you’re paying a pretty penny for something you could make cheaper at home (like muffins). Not to mention, since these items are freshly baked instead of preserved, they tend to grow mold quickly once you get them home.

10. Shredded Cheese …

All Kinds of Shredded Cheese
Cheapism

Shredded cheese can be pricey, and buying a block of cheese is often more cost-effective and it usually tastes and melts better too.

11. … Or Pre-Cut Cheese

Cello Cracker Cut Cheese Variety Pack Costco
Cheapism

Those handy “cracker cuts” cheese slices are handy indeed, but you’re going to spend more for them than you will to buy a block that you slice yourself.

12. Spices & Seasonings

Bottle of spices with spices background
EasyBuy4u/istockphoto

Some stores will charge more for spices and seasonings than others, so shop smart and price them out first. Store brands also tend to be cheaper than brand names like McCormick.

13. Snack-Sized Packs

13. Snack-Sized Packs
Amazon

Individually wrapped snack packs cost more than their whole-box counterparts. Riddle us that. We’d rather buy the box and portion it into snack-sized baggies ourselves.

14. Microwave Popcorn

14. Microwave Popcorn

Buying popcorn kernels is much cheaper than microwave popcorn these days. There’s nothing like the real thing when it comes to flavor either, and microwave popcorn just doesn’t cut it.

15. Coffee Creamer

a bottle of starbucks caramel macchiato coffee creamer
Wilder Shaw / Cheapism

There are an assortment of coffee creamers at the grocery store and a whiplash-inducing range of prices to go along with them. If your tastebuds are partial to Starbucks or International Delight, you’re undoubtedly spending more money than the folks rocking with the store brands or shopping sales.

16. Name-Brand Cereal

null
Juanmonino/istockphoto

Price fatigue is high-risk in the cereal aisle. Chances are if it’s not on sale or off-brand, it’s too expensive to bother with.

17. Name-Brand Chips

Doritos
Cheapism

Like cereal, inflation has tainted chips like Doritos and Ruffles. You’ll pay top-dollar for those brand-name chips if they aren’t on sale, while copycat store brands are comparable in taste and cheaper to boot.

18. Packaged Dips

dips at whole foods
Wilder Shaw / Cheapism

Another item that goes to your refridgerator to die. Those packaged dips look and sound so good, so you grab a box of crackers to go with them. Only, it seems the cracker-to-dip ratio is always off and the dip that remains will hang out in your refrigerator waiting for a new box of crackers to become best friends with. The crackers never come, and the dip goes bad before you can enjoy it all. Womp womp.

19. Energy Drinks

19. Energy Drinks
IvanMiladinovic/istockphoto

Single-serve cans of energy drinks are pricey at the grocery store. If you have to have your carbonated caffeine fix, try buying in bulk at Costco or Sam’s Club for better per-can deals.

20. Party Supplies

gilaxia/istockphoto

Don’t stock up on decorative paper plates, balloons, and party horns at the grocery store. You’ll find much better prices on items like those at the dollar store.

21. Frozen Dinners

Best Frozen Lasagna
Cheapism

If you can make it cheaper without too much hassle, just devote one day a month to preparing meals for your freezer. Enlist someone else in your household or a friend for help to make the task even more manageable. 

22. Frozen Fruit Blends

22. Frozen Fruit Blends

Some frozen fruits are still relatively cheap, but if you start getting into blends, you’ve entered “too expensive to purchase” territory. Grab your berries when they’re on sale or in-season and freeze them yourself. 

23. Diapers and Wipes

23. Diapers and Wipes
CVS

If you’re in your diapers and wipes buying stage of life, we feel the pain of your wallet. But take it from us: your grocery store doesn’t have the best deals on such items. Buy in bulk at Costco or Sam’s or order them on Amazon and you’re sure to pay a better price.

24. Toilet Paper & Paper Towel

Winneconne, WI, USA - 6 Feb 2016: Package Charmin toilet paper.
memoriesarecaptured/istockphoto

We all remember when COVID struck in 2020 and you had to buy toilet paper wherever it was readily available. Folks have since calmed down and stopped the TP hoarding and we’re here to say that the only place to buy your paper products is Sam’s or Costco. Only at the grocery store in a pinch, if you have coupons, or there’s an impossible-to-resist sale.

25. Vitamins

Organic Vegan Gummy vitamins for children coming out of the plastic jar
Juanmonino/istockphoto

Grocery stores have an entire aisle devoted to vitamins, but that doesn’t mean you should spend your money on them. Outside of sales, vitamin prices at the grocery store don’t stack up against the likes of Costco. 

26. Batteries

Chiang Mai, Thailand - June 13, 2011: Four Energizer brand AA size alkaline batteries isolated on a white background.
oneclearvision/istockphoto

Batteries are a giant no-no at the grocery store. You can absolutely find these cheaper elsewhere, like Amazon, Costco, or Sam’s Club.

27. Over-the-Counter Medications

Tylenol display at Walmart
Tylenol, Walmart, 11/2015, by Mike Mozart of TheToyChannel and JeepersMedia on YouTube #Tylenol by Mike Mozart ((CC BY))

Like vitamins, the price of over-the-counter medications like allergy meds or pain relief is available in better deals at wholesale clubs than grocery stores.

28. Paper Plates

Paper plates stacked
Kameleon007/istockphoto

Paper plates have gotten so expensive that it almost doesn’t feel like a joke anymore to refer to them as “fine china.” The best way to buy these is by going to Costco or Sam’s instead of the grocery store.

29. Probiotic Sodas

all 10 poppi prebiotic soda flavors
Poppi

Probiotic sodas are all the rage right now and they have the price tag to prove it. If you’ve got to hop on this craze, do it with the help of Costco or Sam’s Club because the grocery store doesn’t do you many favors in the mark-down department on these.

Meet the Writer

Rachel is a Michigan-based writer who has dabbled in a variety of subject matter throughout her career. As a mom of multiple young children, she tries to maintain a sustainable lifestyle for her family. She grows vegetables in her garden, gets her meat in bulk from local farmers, and cans fruits and vegetables with friends. Her kids have plenty of hand-me-downs in their closets, but her husband jokes that before long, they might need to invest in a new driveway thanks to the frequent visits from delivery trucks dropping off online purchases (she can’t pass up a good deal, after all). You can reach her at [email protected].