Aldi is touted for its affordable imported grocery items, and devout shoppers at the store know that one of the biggest draws is the cheese section. And no, we’re not talking about the blocks of Colby Jack or shredded mozzarella (although those are great go-tos, too). Aldi has an impressive selection of imported cheeses from Gouda to white cheddar, and Redditors love sharing their favorites. We highlighted some of the best cheeses at Aldi that come highly recommended.
Aged Reserve White Cheddar
There are several varieties of white cheddar cheese at Aldi, and the “black label” is a favorite among Redditors. One user commented, “The price point is excellent, and its taste/texture is by far the best cheddar I’ve ever had. Great find!”
Honey Goat Cheese Log
Redditors are all in agreement that Aldi’s goat cheeses are good across the board, but the variety that came up the most when users discussed the best flavors was honey (by a landslide). One commenter suggests the best way to enjoy this cheese is by slathering it on a piece of Aldi’s toasted round sourdough bread.
Cranberry White Cheddar
During my research for this article, I was admittedly influenced to buy and try this cranberry white cheddar cheese, and I am anything but sorry. Many Redditors remarked that this cheese is only seasonal for them, but some (including me, thankfully) are able to find it outside of the holiday season.
Applewood Smoked Gruyere
When someone calls an Aldi cheese “the best buy in the store,” our ears perk up. This one seems to be a staple among Aldi shoppers.
Balsamic Onion Cheddar
The seasonal cheeses at Aldi are beloved, but the fan favorite of all of them might just be the balsamic onion cheddar. One user commented that due to the cheese’s seasonality (and deliciousness), they had three blocks in their refrigerator, while another made quite the telling claim: “I didn’t think I was a cheese person until this cheese came along.”
Trending on Cheapism
Dill Havarti
Dill has taken over grocery stores in recent years, moving well beyond pickles. The Dill Havarti is one of Aldi’s most popular cheeses, and the store offers other havarti flavors in the same lineup.
Double Gloucester Cheese With Onion and Chive
If you’re looking for a cheese with a bit more bite, the double Gloucester cheese with onion and chive packs flavor. Across Reddit threads, recommendations of this cheese have impressive upvotes.
Specialty Shredded Swiss and Gruyere Cheese
The only shredded cheese to make the cut comes highly recommended by Redditors, and they love sharing the best ways to use it, too. One user commented, “The Swiss/Gruyere makes an awesome grilled cheese. Sourdough bread, cheese, Italian seasoning. Dip sandwich in pasta sauce. Like plussed up cheesy bread.” Others said it’s the perfect cheese for things like French onion soup and omelets.
Sign up for our newsletter
Mature Irish Cheddar Cheese
Because no one wants immature cheddar. One Redditor said the cheese tastes like the good stuff from Amish country while another compared it to Kerrygold.
1,000 Day Aged Gouda Cheese
If you thought the Irish cheddar was mature, the aged Gouda is imported from the Netherlands, where it was aged for 1,000 days. It also comes with an “award-winning cheese” label on the package, as if its other credentials weren’t eye-catching enough.
More Cheese Stories From Cheapism
- The Costco Cheeses You Should Always Buy, According to Members — We looked to Reddit for recommendations from fellow Costco fans — and cheese lovers — on which cheeses to pick up for our next charcuterie board or pizza night.
- 10 Brands of American Cheese, Ranked — In order to find the best of the best, I tasted 10 popular brands available at national grocery stores. Here are my findings.
- Trader Joe’s Popular Cheeses, Ranked — After trying 15 cheeses from Trader Joe’s, here are the ones that rose to the top.
