Cheapism is editorially independent. We may earn a commission if you buy through links on our site.

Vintage toned portrait of a young beautiful brunette woman in London second hand marketplace. She is wearing casual Autumn clothes, an olive green parka jacket, browsing through the stuff in the market.
lechatnoir/istockphoto

Whether you’re a penny-pinching miser, die-hard environmentalist, or staunch anti-consumerists, there are plenty of reasons to buy used. But sometimes buying someone’s hand-me-downs is even more expensive in the long run — or outright dangerous. Here are seven products you should never buy used, according to frugal Redditors.

Related: 7 Everyday Items You Should Never Skimp On, According to Redditors

Helmets

Hard hat helmet used in karting field
Qin Ningzhen/istockphoto

Given that a helmet might be the only thing separating your skull from a hard chunk of asphalt, it’s worth investing in one and buying new. The problem with a used helmet, experts say, is that you won’t know if it’s been in a crash. That said, a used noggin protector is better than nothing.

Related: Mistakes to Avoid When Buying an E-Bike

Car Seats

Image of an Asian Chinese woman fastening seat belt for her baby boy on car safety seat before driving
hxyume/istockphoto

For similar safety reasons, parents should think twice before buying a used car seat. According to Safe Kids Worldwide, you should only buy used if you’re certain of the seat’s history, can check that it hasn’t been recalled, and know that it hasn’t passed its expiration date.

Related: Things You Should Never Buy on Craigslist or eBay

Tires

A photograph comparing a dangerously worn tire beside a newer tire with acceptable tread.
Fertnig/istockphoto

You shouldn’t cheap out on anything that comes between you and the ground, as the saying goes. And that includes tires. Not only will new tires last far longer, but they’re also much safer. “Tires are what keep a car connected to the road,” said Greg Brannon, AAA’s director of Automotive Engineering. “Even the most advanced safety systems rely on a tire’s basic ability to maintain traction, and AAA’s testing shows that wear has a significant impact on how quickly a vehicle can come to a stop in wet conditions to avoid a crash.”

Related: My Frustrating but Frugal Experience at Costco’s Tire Center

Electronics

Background of damaged mobile phones. A bunch of broken smartphones. Used phones stacked on top of each other. Repair services and maintenance of equipment.
Karen Poghosyan/istockphoto

Although Redditors are split on this one, some commenters say that they steer clear of all used tech. “I just don’t trust that the first owner cared for the gadget,” one comment reads. On the flip side, users say that buying pre-owned electronics can save you money, provided you take precautions.  

For more shopping tips, please sign up for our free newsletters.

Mattresses

Cropped view of woman choosing bed in store. Female hand on orthopedic memory foam mattress with comfortable and soft white topper. Concept of consumer and purchase
brizmaker/istockphoto

Ask anyone who’s ever dealt with bed bugs about their experience, and you’ll never buy a used mattress again. The unrelenting, pesky blood-sucking creatures are so dreadful, so hard to get rid of, that you’ll want to burn your apartment down. Skip that chapter in your life and buy a fresh, new mattress straight from the store.

Shoes

Pyramid of shoes, Lyon, France
frederic prochasson/istockphoto

Multiple Redditors say that buying used shoes is a bad idea, partly because the “wear patterns can jack your back.” But not everyone is against secondhand kicks, with one commenter saying that he’s saved hundreds of dollars on premium running shoes that have only been worn a few times.

Underwear

Kanawa_Studio/istockphoto

We think this goes without saying … but it’s probably worth buying new underwear. If you must buy used underwear, be sure to wash it in hot soap and water, which should eliminate any health risks.

Meet the Writer

Maxwell is a California-based writer who got his start in print journalism, a career that satisfies his love of research. That penchant for learning also fuels his desire to be a discerning consumer — whether he’s looking for his next pair of headphones or rock-climbing shoes. When he’s not hunched over his laptop, you can find Maxwell sending routes at the crag, playing Magic: The Gathering, or hanging out with his buddies at the bar. As a UCSC alumnus, he’s also a proud banana slug. You can reach him at [email protected].