When people encounter an unusual situation involving food, whether they are surprised, amused or simply confused, and don’t quite understand what’s going on, they might end up posting about it on Reddit, as is the case with these weird food finds!
Mac & Cheese Apple Pie

Reddit user False-Activity5196 asked what others thought about this boxed apple pie that tasted like Mac and cheese. He also revealed that, upon seeing it on social media, he assumed it was fake, but later found it at the store where he shops. User Galactic_Danger commented: “It says ‘no artificial flavors’, but I think like everything in this box came out of a test tube.”
Burger Bun Plus Sausage

Reddit user Remarkable-Trip6582 combined a hamburger bun with the main ingredient of a hot dog, a sausage, to create a new dish, and asked other users what they would call it. This unusual creation became another of the weird food finds attracting attention in the discussion. User Ambitious-Cow8833 replied: “That’s what I had last night for a midnight snack, and I thought to myself ‘I wonder if anybody else is weird enough to do this’.”
Dove Chocolate Bar

The Dove name is also used for a line of chocolates, which many people enjoy besides the soap and personal care brand Dove, and many people purchase their products, like Reddit user ManufacturerOld337, who asked: “Does anyone else de-chocolate the Dove bars before eating them?” These unusual eating habit made it one of the more amusing weird food finds in the discussion. User UncomfyUnicorn mentioned: “Whenever I have any chocolate covered vanilla thing I eat it like this.”
Pregnant Bell Pepper

Reddit user FlattenedOpossum was surprised when he cut a rather large bell pepper in half and found a smaller, fully formed pepper inside, which he dubbed a ‘baby pepper.’ He also mentioned: “I’m 20 years old and I have never seen a pepper like this. I don’t know if it’s a bonus pepper that is edible or not.” User Total_Tumblewed_870 mentioned: “You can eat them, they don’t taste any different. In my house we consider them good luck.”
Reddit Tomato

Reddit user tacketaciboomer took a photograph of this tomato because of its unusual shape. However, for many of those commenting on the post, it was clear that the tomato was shaped like the Reddit symbol. This distinctive appearance made it now of the more recognizable weird food finds. User No_Cups7883 commented: “That tomato looks like it’s pondering the meaning of life, so how about calling it the existential heirloom?”
Trending on Cheapism
Banana Bread

Reddit user Erecura_70 wasn’t entirely convinced about a banana-flavored bread product that a friend had given him from China. So, he posted the image on Reddit asking if anyone had tried them and mentioning it only had 12 grams of sugar in each bread. This unusual product became another of the weird food finds that caught user’s attention. User Certain-Refuse-2254 replied: “I have tried a few similar alternatives and toast them in an air fryer, slice them into bite-sized pieces and enjoy them with coffee or tea.”
Canned Fish Steaks

Reddit user Excellent-Traffic216 took a photograph of a canned product, fish steaks served in a can with Louisiana hot sauce, and asked if anyone else was familiar with it. He added that he paid $1 for the meal and justified his purchase because he is always down to try anything new. User IceBoxt mentioned: “I used to have a few in the pantry but nowadays most stores seem to be no longer carrying them. Their sardines are just okey, and have a great meaty texture.”
Buttered Four Cheese Bagel Peanut Butter and Jelly with Reese’s

Another of the strange food combinations shared by Reddit users is this sandwich made with a bagel, four types of cheese, peanut butter, jelly, and Reese’s pieces, added, according to Reddit user EclecticFae. He also mentioned that he would make it again, giving it a 10 out of 10 rating. This unusual combination easily earns a place among the weird food finds shared in the discussion. User BurntArnold mentioned: “I’m eating a buttered four cheese bagel as I’m viewing this and have all these things at my house.”
Sign up for our newsletter
Meatball Flavored Lollipop

What is shown in the image is a meatball-flavored lollipop, reportedly a limited edition that IKEA staff discovered in a lounge in Sweden. User samuelmusicman revealed that the brown portion actually tastes somewhat like a meatball, while the rest doesn’t taste good at all. However, the red section does taste like sweetened lingonberry jam. This certainly ranks among the strangest weird food finds in the collection.
Taki Heart

Reddit user mach10nacho spotted a heart-shaped Takis snack while eating the spicy treat. It immediately caught his eye, so he took a photograph of it. This unusual shape made it one of the more memorable weird food finds in the discussion. Some users, such as MacaroonMelodic4048, suggested: “If you didn’t eat it already, try to sell it! People pay good prices for interestingly shaped chips that look like things and this one is crazy!”
Weird Carrot

Some users, like annual-grass-1335, remarked that this strange carrot looked like a new Pokemon. Others, like the person who took the photograph, Reddit user individual-Self516, explained that it’s a carrot that grew in an intricate way, making it difficult to peel or cook. This is another example of the weird food finds that can emerge from an ordinary grocery purchase.
Kiwi with The Skin On

The vast majority of people eat kiwis but peel them first, which is why it was unusual when Reddit user Mevi- posted a photo of the fruit with the skin still on. He added: “I like to eat mine with the skin on, for extra flavor and probably a good source of fiber. It’s obviously washed properly.” The different approach to eating fruit adds another entry to the weird food finds shared on Reddit. User MakeSouthBayGR8Again commented: “It’s good for your health if it is ripe enough.”
Conclusion

From an apple pie that tastes like Mac and cheese to a meatball-flavored lollipop, with weird food finds reveal some of the unusual things people encounter when it comes to food. Whether they’re surprising combinations, unexpected discoveries, or peculiar flavors, these examples show that unusual food experiences can turn up when you least expect them.