Cheapism is editorially independent. We may earn a commission if you buy through links on our site.

A United States Treasury check partially covers a U.S. Individual Income Tax Return form 1040, symbolizing a tax refund payment. The Treasury check features the Statue of Liberty and financial details.
cabania/istockphoto

If you already filed your taxes and your refund didn’t magically jump by hundreds (or thousands) of dollars, you might be letting out a disgruntled, “What the heck?” After all, according to new data from the Internal Revenue Service, the average tax refund so far this year is nearly 11% higher than it was at this point last year.

That’s the headline. The reality, as usual, is messier. Some people are seeing noticeably bigger refunds. Others are getting basically the same amount as last year. And a not-insignificant number of filers are staring at smaller refunds and wondering who exactly this “average” is supposed to represent.

The Average Is Doing a Lot of Work Here

Early IRS data shows refunds north of $2,200 on average so far this season, which sounds great until you remember how averages work. A handful of very large refunds can pull that number up quickly, even while plenty of people see little change — or even a decline. Tax season, like everything else in the economy these days, also isn’t evenly distributed.

Lower-income filers tend to file early, while higher earners often wait longer. As more complex returns come in, the average refund typically rises before leveling out later in the season. In other words, this number is still very much in flux. That alone explains part of the gap between the data and how people feel about it. But not all of it.

Tax Credits Make or Break the Refund

This year’s bigger refunds are being driven largely by tax credits, especially those tied to income level and children. If you qualify for refundable credits, your refund can jump dramatically. If you don’t, the “boost” may be barely noticeable. That’s why two households with similar incomes can walk away with wildly different results. It’s also why the idea that everyone would see a big refund bump was always a little optimistic.

What People Are Actually Getting Back

On Reddit, where people are nothing if not honest about their finances, the reactions are (as expected) all over the place.

Some filers say their refunds are way down, even though nothing about their lives changed. One person reported getting $3,200 less than last year with the same job, salary, and deductions. Another said their refund dropped by $1,300 despite claiming the same dependents.

Others saw barely any movement at all. “I only got like $100 more this year,” one commenter wrote. Another couple said their refund went from $790 last year to $810 this year — technically an increase, but only one big enough to buy a jug of laundry detergent, so … meh.

Then there’s the opposite end of the spectrum. A separate thread lit up after one filer asked whether a refund north of $25,000 could possibly be real. That post prompted equal parts disbelief and envy, with other parents chiming in to say their refunds were nowhere near that high — even with multiple kids. Several noted that unusually large refunds often come down to a very specific mix of credits, income thresholds, and withholding.

One commenter summed it up bluntly: If your refund is massive, there’s a decent chance you overpaid throughout the year. Which is great now, but less great when you think about what that money could’ve been doing in your paycheck.

So … Is This a ‘Good’ Tax Season?

On average, refunds are higher. But averages don’t pay bills. People do. For some households, this tax season brings real relief. For others, it’s a shrug. And for a growing number of filers, the takeaway is confusion, because the widely advertised refund boost simply didn’t show up.

More From Cheapism

High angle view of a young woman using a laptop computer to organize her finances.
micro10x/shutterstock

Meet the Writer

Rachel is a Michigan-based writer who has dabbled in a variety of subject matter throughout her career. As a mom of multiple young children, she tries to maintain a sustainable lifestyle for her family. She grows vegetables in her garden, gets her meat in bulk from local farmers, and cans fruits and vegetables with friends. Her kids have plenty of hand-me-downs in their closets, but her husband jokes that before long, they might need to invest in a new driveway thanks to the frequent visits from delivery trucks dropping off online purchases (she can’t pass up a good deal, after all). You can reach her at [email protected].